| All-SAC | 1st Team | 2nd Team |
| Quarterback | Luke Goode, junior, Homestead | Jon Barnes Jr., senior, Snider |
| Running Back | Braeden Hardwick, junior, Homestead Alex Holliday-Robinson, senior, North Side Keshaun Fields, senior, Wayne Lenny Bennett, senior, Snider | Amir Drew, junior, Concordia Jeremiah Green, senior, Northrop |
| Receiver | Alonzo Derrick, senior, Snider Jake Archbold, senior, Homestead | Jalen Vanderbosch, senior, Concordia Layton Mitchell, senior, Carroll |
| Tight End | Griffin Little, senior, Homestead | Eddie, Bransfield, junior, Carroll |
| Tackle | Randy Holtz, senior, Snider Luke Wiginton, senior, Bishop Dwenger | Reeve Muncie, junior, Carroll Owen Hire, junior, Homestead |
| Guard | Joe Henry, senior, Bishop Dwenger Brady Parker, junior, Homestead | Brandon Brundige, junior, North Side Simon Twiss, senior, Wayne |
| Center | Robert McCrory, senior, Homestead | Orion Chenery, senior, Carroll |
| Kicker | Trevor Horton, senior, Carroll | Gunnar Fry, senior, Homestead |
| Defensive End | Theo Redmond, senior, North Side Reggie Blackmon, senior, Wayne Jalen Wiggins, senior, Snider | Nigel Robertson, senior, Northrop Wes Stephens, senior, Carroll |
| Defensive Tackle | Gianini Belizaire, senior, Snider Larry Sible, senior, Carroll Maxwell Burney, junior, South Side | Jordan Watercutter, senior, Bishop Dwenger Vinnie Fiacable, junior, Bishop Dwenger Will Derrick, senior, Bishop Luers |
| Linebacker | Cam Rogers, senior, Homestead Devon Tippmann, junior, Bishop Dwenger Luke Palmer, junior, Homestead Hunter Mertz, junior, Carroll Kameron Trotter, senior, Snider | Lashon Miller, junior, North Side Hayden Ellinger, senior, Bishop Dwenger Nick Birkmeier, senior, Bishop Luers Matthew Ottenweller, senior, Carroll |
| Defensive Back | Jayshawn Underwood, senior, Snider Patrick Finley, senior, Bishop Dwenger Antoine Scott, senior, Northrop Ray Vollmer, senior, Carroll | Jalen Harris, senior, North Side Lincoln Lantz, senior, Carroll Te’Noah Ridley, senior, Northrop Griffin Eifert, senior, Bishop Dwenger |
| Punter | Trevor Hapner, sophomore, South Side | Ben Jennings, senior, Bishop Luers |
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Bishop Dwenger | Patrick O’Keefe Alex Fosnaugh Nolan Fischer Josh Scrogham Brenden Lytle Louis Tippmann Patrick Finley | Joseph Bulanda Michael Ledo Jr. Owen Sharp Gage Renbarger Lucas Krohn Howie Steele Callan Stauffer |
| Bishop Luers | Alex Workman Cam Hedgecock Jamic Johnson Ben Rectanus | Ramon Anderson C.J. Hale Drake Carter |
| Carroll | Mason Englert Kyler Bills Jeffrey Becker Aaron Jacquay | Craig McGinnis Cade Dinan Tucker Steely |
| Concordia | Cooper Harris Sam Hudson Kam Vanderbosch | Kam Johnson Brandon Davis Tyler Grossman |
| Homestead | Jared Kistler Matt Miller Nik Martin Cole Etchison | Morgan Lamon Ryan Burton Donnovan Leonard |
| Northrop | Vaughn Crews Qualen Pettus Adrian Sewell TaQuan White Damarius Cowen | Tarik Bajgoric Jose Reducindo Jordan Young Darrius Sanders |
| North Side | Jacob Lambert Aspen Pippert-Board Duce Taylor Jordan Turner Preston McElroy | T.Q. Redmond Davonte Rogers Auntral Franklin Aerion McCarter |
| Snider | Jermaine Wells Dillon Duff Andrew Sims Nic Myles Chris Arita D.J. Moore Kyler Davis Cameron Miller Nick Pezley | Tavian Rucklos Domanick Moon Caivon Spencer Isaiah Maxwell Brock Widman Tavarious Easley-Jones Donavin Eley Trent Rider Zach Tyndall |
| South Side | Davonte Alford Fred Starks | Jeremiah Powell Jaylen Lattimore |
| Wayne | Cam Webb Caldijaun Mitchell Matt Spriggs Authur Mhoon Ronald Elliot Cam Toles Shawn Collins Kaysan Jones Aidan Meek | Desmond Davis Ky’Ren Johnson Ebon Person Mehki Lee Nate Moore Ethan Dumas Antjuan Schneider Andrew Kennedy |
