All-Conference Football
| Season | Type | Honor | Position | Player | Year | School |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Matt Tillapaugh | Snider | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Andrew Krouse | Bishop Luers | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Josh Clinkenbeard | Snider | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Jamie Bopp | Snider | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Matt Gualdoni | Northrop | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Andy Knapp | Snider | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Gabe Ortiz | Bishop Luers | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Ross Paris | Snider | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Anthony Young | Snider | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Thomas Hammock | Bishop Luers | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Sean Casey | Harding | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Courtney Temple | Snider | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Pat Mendoza | Northrop | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Zack Lauer | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Robert Brown | Harding | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Matt Govan | Wayne | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jordan Gigli | Bishop Luers | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Corey Jones | Snider | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Courtland Clancy | Wayne | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Ben Rogers | Northrop | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Josh Egts | Bishop Luers | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Robbiel Moore | Snider | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Kyle Christman | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Matt Foss | Snider | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Matt Gabet | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Vessie Pirtle | Wayne | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Terrence Miles | North Side | |
| 1998 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Kevin Morrow | Bishop Luers | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Jovan Witherspoon | Bishop Luers | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Davon Fowlkes | Snider | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Trai Essex | Harding | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Adrian Stiffarm | Northrop | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Travis Newby | Harding | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Casey Andrews | Northrop | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Mike Morin | Snider | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Alex Carter | Harding | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Ronsen Underwood | Northrop | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Larry Bostic | South Side | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Kamal Macon | Concordia | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | John Murray | Northrop | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Kyle Lindsay | Bishop Luers | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Josh Every | Snider | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Ryan Hicks | Snider | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Adam Anspach | North Side | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Corey Jones | Snider | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Kameron Bailey | South Side | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Chris Wiggins | Wayne | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Ben Rogers | Northrop | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Kevin McDavid | South Side | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Robbiel Moore | Snider | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Brandon Lyons | Harding | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Joey Conner | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Aurelion Boughton | South Side | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Ronnie Jones | North Side | |
| 1999 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Vern Martin | Wayne | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Ryan Hahaj | Northrop | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | T.J. Goodman | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Trai Essex | Harding | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Pat Burkhart | Bishop Luers | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Adrian Stiffarm | Northrop | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Greg Wagner | Snider | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Anthony Jones | South Side | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Andy Niezer | Bishop Luers | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Kyle Lindsay | Bishop Luers | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Michael Ledo | Bishop Luers | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Larry Bostic | South Side | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | David Tubbs | Harding | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Cameron Smith | North Side | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Lindsey Deason | Snider | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Zac Lauer | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Adam Griffith | Bishop Luers | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Dan Demars | Northrop | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Anthony Spencer | Bishop Luers | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Andrew Woodson | Wayne | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Detrick Hunt | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Brian Kurtz | Bishop Luers | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Chuck Geyer | Elmhurst | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | John Steinhofer | Snider | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Stacy Butler | South Side | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Olajuwon LeShore | Wayne | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Matt Millhouse | Bishop Luers | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Jamie Holman | Northrop | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Ronnie Jones | North Side | |
| 2000 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Garien Hudson | Snider | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | T.J. Goodman | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Steve Shank | Bishop Luers | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Tywan Cole | Harding | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Adam Griffith | Bishop Luers | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Tom Guin | Snider | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Pat Oxley | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Josh Moore | South Side | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Phil Cowherd | Harding | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Mark Anderson | Concordia | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Nick Klee | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Kyle Lindsay | Bishop Luers | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Larry Bostic | South Side | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | J.J. Robinson | Snider | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Bryan Payton | Concordia | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Cameron Smith | North Side | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Clint Bontempo | Wayne | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Chris Custard | Bishop Luers | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Doug Bush | Snider | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Anthony Spencer | Bishop Luers | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jason Turnage | North Side | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Lorenzo Wims | Snider | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Brian Kurtz | Bishop Luers | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Ryan Egts | Bishop Luers | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Derek Frye | Northrop | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Brandon Logan | Snider | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Jake Sharin | Wayne | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Casey Johnson | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Matt Millhouse | Bishop Luers | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Courtney Reese | Harding | |
| 2001 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Bernard Pollard | South Side | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Jonathon Lapsley | Concordia | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Reggie Smith | Harding | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Josh Gaines | Northrop | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Ben Wyss | Bishop Luers | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Marcus Wagner | Snider | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Tommy Nguyen | Northrop | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Jon Gerkin | Snider | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Nick Klee | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Ryan Doerffler | Concordia | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | John Weaver | Harding | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Jhromy Martinez | Bishop Luers | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Aaron Lane | Snider | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Bryan Payton | Concordia | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Josh Macke | Concordia | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Jon Rocholl | Snider | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Jeff Lauer | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Tyler Trappe | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Matt Tamez | Snider | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Lorenzo Wims | Snider | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jeremy Billingsley | North Side | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Chase Gorman | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Brandon Logan | Snider | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Charles Bailey | Northrop | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Antoine Calligan | South Side | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Nick Murray | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Bernard Pollard | South Side | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Kevin King | Snider | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Dan Fox | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2002 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Jason Egts | Bishop Luers | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Selwyn Lymon | Harding | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | James Hardy | Elmhurst | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Josh Gaines | Northrop | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Brian Hilts | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Tony Wallace | Snider | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Jamarcus Green | Snider | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Brian Smiley | Harding | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Germarcus King | Harding | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Reggie Smith | Harding | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Justin Wynn | Snider | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Bryan Payton | Concordia | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Charles Bailey | Northrop | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Julian Noel | Harding | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Josh Macke | Concordia | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Jon Rocholl | Snider | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Erik Kumming | Bishop Luers | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Travis Craven | Snider | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Antonio Beasley | Northrop | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Marquez Thornton | Harding | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jeremy Sanders | Northrop | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jerome Bostic | Snider | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Courtney Pearson | South Side | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | David Mattlock | Northrop | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Jon Lapsley | Concordia | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Mikle Gardner | Snider | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Donathan Woods | South Side | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Ryan Reynolds | Snider | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Brandon Bryant | Harding | |
| 2003 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Matt Bienz | Northrop | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Selwyn Lymon | Harding | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Dwight Eatmon | Concordia | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Brandon Davis | Bishop Luers | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Shawn Atherton | Snider | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Josh DeLuc | Snider | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Willie Ellis | South Side | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Brent Egts | Bishop Luers | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Andrew Ollis | Snider | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Kyle Christen | North Side | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Justin Parker | Wayne | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Quale Lewis | Snider | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Randy Harris | North Side | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Tosin Ikudabo | South Side | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Jon Rochell | Snider | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Kenny Paul | Concordia | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Travis Craven | Snider | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Michael Brune | Concordia | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Pierre Taylor | Harding | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Josh Doctor | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jordan Applegate | Snider | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Jarrell Hunter | Harding | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Colin Brodmerkel | Bishop Luers | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Quinten Scott | South Side | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Jeremy Hicov | North Side | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Steve Ramthun | Snider | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Donathan Woods | South Side | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Artis Chambers | Snider | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Dan Kimes | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2004 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Mike Woods | Northrop | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Marquelle Suel | Harding | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Devin Anderson | Elmhurst | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Mitch Vanderau | Snider | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Ryan Myers | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Bryce Egley | Snider | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Steve Seculoff | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Kilo Gaines | South Side | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Steve Fiacable | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Ben Hendricks | Bishop Luers | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | John Goodman | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Jermarkis Willis | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Rod Smith | Harding | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Ray Byers | Wayne | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | At Large | Dillon Painter | Snider | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Aaron Thomas | Snider | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Clayton Pusey | Concordia | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Aaron Hendricks | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Brandon Knox | Concordia | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Malcolm Riley | Snider | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Greg Svarczkopf | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Desmond Kenner | Elmhurst | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Mick Mentzer | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Tyquan Hammock | Bishop Luers | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Alex Hippenhammer | Snider | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Aris Allen | North Side | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Adrien Spencer | Bishop Luers | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | David Swinehart | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Taylor Howenstine | North Side | |
| 2007 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Xavier Carr | Harding | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Austin Coleman | Harding | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Cam Bailey | Snider | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Tyler Eifert | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Gus Springman | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Dmitri Gholston | Bishop Luers | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Kam Coleman | North Side | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Justin Dinius | Concordia | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Stephen Fiacable | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Matt Elliott | Snider | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Rod Smith | Harding | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Robby Kimes | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Ty Tubbs | North Side | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Tony Kebede | Bishop Luers | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Quinn Schafer | Bishop Luers | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Logan Powell | Northrop | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Brian Fogler | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Zach Barnes | Snider | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Steve Seculoff | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | LaWane Stevenson | Snider | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Austin Tillman | Bishop Luers | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Tyquan Hammock | Bishop Luers | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Marqueen Suel | Harding | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Matt Tippman | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Devon Rush | Snider | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Dillon Painter | Snider | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Taylor Howenstine | North Side | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Xavier Carr | Harding | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Landon Feichter | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2008 | All SAC | 1st Team | At Large | Stephen Scott | Harding | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Michael Rogers | Bishop Luers | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Karrington Eaton | North Side | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Addison Dellinger | Snider | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Ryan Watercutter | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Casey Baker | Bishop Luers | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Cameron McCalla | Northrop | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Ruben Holcomb | Snider | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Kendric Thomas | Snider | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Ta'Quan Walker | North Side | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Blake Bowers | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | James Knapke | Bishop Luers | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Jaylon Smith | Bishop Luers | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | John Nelson | Snider | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Steve Espinoza | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Connor Friesner | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Will Coursen-Carr | South Side | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Jordan Starks | Bishop Luers | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Quinton Walker | South Side | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Donte Bowen | Snider | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Marko Thomas | North Side | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Everett Green | Bishop Luers | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Montez Brooks | Bishop Luers | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | James Starks | Snider | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Anthony Linnear | North Side | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Connor Mccann | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Curtis Williams | South Side | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Evan Feichter | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Jerrell Holman | Northrop | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Kendrick Mullen | Bishop Luers | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Marq Rogers | Concordia | |
| 2011 | All SAC | 1st Team | At Large | Austin Rife | North Side | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Michael Rogers | Bishop Luers | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Spencer Cowherd | Northrop | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Addison Dellinger | Snider | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Russell Collins | North Side | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Ruben Holcomb | Snider | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Andrew Meyers | Snider | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Nathan Braster | South Side | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Travis Leonard | Snider | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | C. J. Jackson | North Side | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Anthony Linnear | North Side | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Aaron Thomas | South Side | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Donovan Clark | South Side | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Je'Norie Smith | Snider | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Josh Spitnale | Snider | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Colin Brockhouse | Northrop | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Jaylon Smith | Bishop Luers | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Adam Whisler | Snider | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Blake Bowers | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | W. R. Sanders | North Side | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Dan Beckman | Bishop Luers | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Weston Painter | Snider | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Tony Perugini | Concordia | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Aaron LaMaster | Bishop Luers | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Devontay Reese | Snider | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Joseph Griffin | Wayne | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Marq Rogers | Concordia | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Ryan Watercutter | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Kendrick Mullen | Bishop Luers | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Nick Reese | Snider | |
| 2012 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Terrance Fincher | Wayne | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Jake Minich | Concordia | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Zach McKinstry | North Side | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Ryan Watercutter | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Sean Englert | Snider | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Jari Dada | Wayne | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Andre Green | North Side | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Shane Hurt | Snider | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Nathan Niese | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | David Morrison | Concordia | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Michael Lovette | North Side | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Nick Cook | North Side | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Donovan Clark | South Side | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Austin Yarbro | Wayne | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | At Large | Mike Fiacable | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Edgar Maldonado | Wayne | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Stephen Colligan | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Austin Pearson | Northrop | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Nathan Braster | South Side | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Alex Schenkel | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | WR Sanders | North Side | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Joe Thomas | Wayne | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Tony Perugini | Concordia | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Rahju Blackmon | Snider | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Nic Morken | Bishop Luers | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Latavion Guy | North Side | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Antonio Blackmon | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Kavon Anderson | North Side | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Dionte Walker | South Side | |
| 2013 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Kye Black | Wayne | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Austin Mack | Bishop Luers | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Tyrell Johnson | Bishop Luers | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Russell Davies | Snider | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Sean Englert | Snider | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | David Peters | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Jyaire Carr | Snider | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Jeremy Herber | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Eddie Elder | Wayne | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Keion Powers | Wayne | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | At Large | Noah Wezensky | Bishop Luers | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Austin Yarbro | Wayne | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Peterson Kerlegrand | Concordia | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Jeremiah Gaston | Bishop Luers | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Travis Eckert | Bishop Luers | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Logan Capps | North Side | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Cameron Fox | Northrop | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Auston Robertson | Wayne | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | C. J. Mccarter | Bishop Luers | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Joe Thomas | Wayne | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Daemen Williams | Bishop Luers | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Matt Swartz | Snider | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jackson Grahovac | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Marcus Stepp | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Tyson Whitner | North Side | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Curt Stephens | Wayne | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Joe Williams | Snider | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Jessie Bates | Snider | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Isaac Morken | Bishop Luers | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Deion Powers | Wayne | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Kye Black | Wayne | |
| 2014 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Jaylin Fowler | Snider | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Austin Mack | Bishop Luers | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | David Turner | Snider | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Ben Skowronek | Homestead | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Kenneth Hurt | Snider | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Landon Campbell | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Jeremy Herber | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Trevor Thomas | Snider | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Grant Purlee | Homestead | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Aidan Smith | Carroll | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Isaac Stiebling | Snider | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | At Large | Daniel Sparks | Concordia | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Peterson Kerlegrand | Concordia | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Amaun Clark | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Money Woods | Snider | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Cameron Fox | Northrop | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Logan Capps | North Side | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | James Jamicich | Carroll | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Marcus Green | Snider | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Frank Yanko | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Daemen Williams | Bishop Luers | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Joc Thomas | Wayne | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Dylan Conner | Carroll | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Jonari Brown | Snider | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Tyson Whitner | North Side | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Peter Winklejohn | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Blake Schumacher | Carroll | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Austin Burns | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Matt Anderson | Homestead | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | David Johnson | North Side | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Austin Krider | Homestead | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Malik Bramley | Snider | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Tight End | Justin Dippold | Bishop Luers | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Tackle | Trey Freeman | Concordia | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Tackle | Jeff Tran | Northrop | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Guard | Landon Myers | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Guard | Mick Palmer | Bishop Luers | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Guard | Zach Starks | Bishop Luers | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Center | Nick Maguire | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Center | Marcus Reeder | Bishop Luers | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Drew Keszei | Homestead | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | J'Lyn Charlton | Bishop Luers | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Landon Durnell | Homestead | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Jason Ash | Northrop | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Paul Buisman | Snider | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Joe Knepper | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Trent Morgan | Snider | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Colin Burns | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Terrell Moore | South Side | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Savion Golden | Bishop Luers | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Tico Brown | Homestead | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Zach Schaefer | Carroll | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Drew Bordner | Concordia | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Moses Girardot | Homestead | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Drew Brelsfoard | Snider | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Gavin Pelkington | Carroll | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Zach Norton | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Jack Givens | Carroll | |
| 2015 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Tahj Curry | Homestead | |
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ryan Berghoff | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nick Brady | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mitch Effinger | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tim Fean | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | John Federspiel | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nick Faicable | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Noah Freimuth | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Louis Garrett | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jared Gernhardt | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Alex Grotemat | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mike Hake | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Luther Hall | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jack Harris | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Matt Litchfield | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Sean McAbee | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | David Obergfell | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Blake Podschlne | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Joe Steigmeyer | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nolan Sipe | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ian Stroud | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Banks | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nick Carroll | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Elijah Jett | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jack Johnston | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Connor Neeley | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nathan Pritchard | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Chance Ritschard | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tre Underwood | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Justin Becker | Carroll | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cody Dinan | Carroll | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brandon Kimes | Carroll | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tyler Lengerich | Carroll | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Hayden Nieuwlandt | Carroll | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nick Novotny | Carroll | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Schmeling | Carroll | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jack Shannon | Carroll | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Colton Grahovac | Concordia | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Hunter Terrell | Homestead | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dakota Ault | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Isaac Balfout | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Markus Brown | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Evan Clark | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Austin Denicolo | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kalen Desrosiers | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Marvail Hamilton | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | DeJuan Harris | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dyreece Howard | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Chris Jacobs | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Bryshon Lockett | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jalen Lockett | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Maleke Lymon | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Soe Moe | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Montrail Moore | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Arion Nieves | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ivan Nycum | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Logan Snyder | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Lionel Sorrells | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gage Stier | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jaquai Williams | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Marvin Williams | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Hakeen Woodruff | North Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Heath Ault | Northrop | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Joey Brooks | Northrop | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Diquann Conwell | Northrop | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Dickinson | Northrop | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tristan Douglass | Northrop | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Casey Lawrence | Northrop | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | D'Shondre Miller | Northrop | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Garrett Schoenle | Northrop | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ashton Seaney | Northrop | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mike Snyder | Northrop | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tyree Washington | Northrop | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Zenden Dellinger | Snider | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Gorman | Snider | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Bryson Haft | Snider | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mac Hippenhammer | Snider | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Lawrence Johnson | Snider | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Will Johnson | Snider | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Zach McDowell | Snider | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Justin Munoz | Snider | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Damarious Ridley | Snider | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dominick Scott | Snider | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Taj Starks | Snider | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ronnie Barnett | South Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Marquelyn Davis | South Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Marcalin Hairston | South Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | K.J. King | South Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | C.J. Morris | South Side | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Anthony Black | Wayne | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Delta Chapman | Wayne | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Daylon Hart | Wayne | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ahmaud Hill | Wayne | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Javier Johnson | Wayne | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Devonair Kelsaw | Wayne | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Joey Mullins | Wayne | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jacob Newton | Wayne | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Fabeion Pearson | Wayne | ||
| 2015 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | David Torres | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Mac Hippenhammer | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Mark Mallers | Concordia | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Bryson Haft | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Zenden Dellinger | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | DC Mickey | Homestead | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Sam Henry | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Evan Elston | Homestead | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Grant Purlee | Homestead | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Peter Morrison | Concordia | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Money Woods | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | J’lyn Charlton | Bishop Luers | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Jordan Presley | Homestead | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Paul Buisman | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Jack Shannon | Carroll | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | At Large | Colton Grahovac | Concordia | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | At Large | Joe Thornson | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Will Johnson | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Tico Brown | Homestead | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Lawrence Johnson | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Frank Yanko | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Zachary McDowell | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Austin France | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Peter Winkeljohn | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Drew Bordner | Concordia | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Moses Girardot | Homestead | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Matt Anderson | Homestead | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Dom Slaughter | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Peterson Kerlegrand | Concordia | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Ahmaud Hill | Wayne | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Justin Becker | Carroll | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Dashon Bussell | Bishop Luers | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Dylan Dixon | Carroll | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Nick Webb | Concordia | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Zach Starks | Bishop Luers | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Christian Smith | South Side | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Center | Jacob Doll | Concordia | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Garrett Schoehle | Northrop | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Christian Covington | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Nic Novotny | Carroll | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Casey Lawrence | Northrop | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Jack Shannon | Carroll | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Bailey Salary | Wayne | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Luther Hall | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Jake Ostrowski | Carroll | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Trey Freeman | Concordia | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Ryan Nguyen | Carroll | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Dakota Ault | North Side | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Nick Parker | Carroll | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Tristan Wells | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | R. J. Carpenter | Homestead | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Hakeem Woodruff | North Side | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Mitch Effinger | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Connor Tapp | Carroll | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Javier Johnson | Wayne | |
| 2016 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Taj Starks | Snider | |
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Isaac Blume | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Amaun Clark | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Steven Nix | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tommy Steel | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Joe Tippmann | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Anton Berry | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dominic Easley | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Justin Gaston | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mitch Gigli | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ty Hambright | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Peyton Howe | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Chance Ritschard | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jimmy Sturm | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tre Underwood | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jonathan Becker | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tommy Bobay | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Connor Call | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Blake Castetter | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cameron Dargis | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Blake Eley | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Noah Hines | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jesse Lawson | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jack Miguel | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ian Miller | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tyler Parker | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Marshall Pranger | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Schmeling | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Caleb Sutton | Carroll | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Keontre Hughes | Concordia | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Preston Kerlegrand | Concordia | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Keaton Koehlinger | Concordia | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gabe Vohs | Concordia | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Noah Knepper | Homestead | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Eric Peters | Homestead | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Grant Raber | Homestead | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cameron Shannon | Homestead | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Hunter Terrell | Homestead | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ivory Wilson | Homestead | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jiya Wright | Homestead | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kalen Desrosiers | North Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jalen Lockett | North Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ezra Wilcox | North Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jared Wright | North Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ben Arruza | Northrop | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Davieun Berry | Northrop | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Joey Books | Northrop | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Neeko Braster | Northrop | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cameron Cephus | Northrop | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Connor Stout | Northrop | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Heath Ault | Northrop | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Antwone Washington | Northrop | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Viktor Stjepic | Northrop | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Keishon Edwards | Northrop | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Vince Campbell | Snider | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Garrett Carroll | Snider | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Simon Dellinger | Snider | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Gorman | Snider | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mike Haupert | Snider | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Colton Hinton | Snider | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brandon Kocks | Snider | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Damarious Ridley | Snider | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | DeAndrew Stroud | Snider | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ronnie Barnett | South Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Torrese Bobo | South Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Marquelyn Davis | South Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Marcalin Hairston | South Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dennis Johnson | South Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Isaac Johnson | South Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gerald Little | South Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Christian Smith | South Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jacob Torres | South Side | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Darius Alexander | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cameron Chambers | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Delta Chapman | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Diontre Collins-Jones | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Patrick Cotton | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Zach Daniels | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Lukas Fender | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Terrance Frison | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Qamari Hassan | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Devonair Kelsaw | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Latrell Lapsley | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Calvin Mitchell | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Fabeion Pearson | Wayne | ||
| 2016 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Craig Young | Wayne | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Justin Becker | Carroll | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Trevin Taylor | Homestead | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Simon Dellinger | Snider | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Joe Tippmann | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Porter Haught | Homestead | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Mitchell Campbell | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Jackson Reed | Snider | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Mitch Gigli | Bishop Luers | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Jiya Wright | Homestead | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Jack Miguel | Carroll | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Keishon Edwards | Northrop | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Christian Covington | Snider | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Jack James | Snider | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Bailey Salary | Wayne | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Darius Alexander | Wayne | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Isaac Johnson | South Side | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Trey Freeman | Concordia | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Lawrence Johnson | Snider | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Tico Brown | Homestead | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Isaac Blume | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Jack Tranquill | Carroll | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Dalyn Hart | Wayne | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Austin France | Snider | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Ethan Hoover | Snider | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Cameron Shannon | Homestead | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Justin Gaston | Bishop Luers | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Thomas Davis | South Side | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Kamari Anderson-Drew | Concordia | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | David Nakasen | Snider | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Craig Young | Wayne | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Tight End | R.J. Armstrong | North Side | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Lukas Fender | Wayne | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Cameron Cephus | Northrop | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Chris Berghoff | Homestead | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Center | Jacob Doll | Concordia | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Michael Haupert | Snider | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Jordan Presley | Bishop Luers | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Marcalin Hairston | South Side | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Michael Garrett | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Michael Garrett | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Liam Fletcher | Concordia | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Aaron Niedzwiecki | Homestead | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Jacob Fabini | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Terell Griffin | Carroll | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Zach McDowell | Snider | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Brandon Kocks | Snider | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Camden Rogers | Homestead | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Camari Harris | Bishop Luers | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Ka’Shawn Bass | South Side | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Alec Watercutter | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Blake Eley | Carroll | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Dre Walton | Wayne | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Hunter Causey | Snider | |
| 2017 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Jalen Lockett | North Side | |
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tommy Steele | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Bradley Black | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Alex Kolkman | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Chip Clark | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | A.J. Brady | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | T.J. Tippmann | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Will Kolar | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | T.J. McGarry | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Sam Obergfell | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Sam Verslype | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Allen Jackson | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Trez Jordan | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gabe Hendricks | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jack Sweeney | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Peyton Howe | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ty Hambright | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Camdyn Childers | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dom Easley | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jonathan Becker | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Logan Belleville | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Reed Davis | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Reed Diller | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Braxton Gropengieser | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mason Gynn | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brock Ingram | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Austin Lineback | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | George Rongos | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cam Shank | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Hudson Walker | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cobey Malcolm | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Bryce Pelkington | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gaven Vogt | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Orion Chenery | Carroll | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Keaton Koehlinger | Concordia | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Marcus Morrow | Concordia | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Preston Kerlegrand | Concordia | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Grant Raber | Homestead | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Austin Layton | Homestead | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jack Klien | Homestead | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Auntral Franklin | North Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Reggie Telemaque | North Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Will Epperson | North Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brandon Brundige | North Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Deantre McGown | North Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Lawrence Davis | North Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Quincy Moore | North Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Sam Dick | North Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jevonn Taylor | North Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Arvante Taylor | North Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Chris Thomas | Northrop | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tyler Clibon | Northrop | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ty Smith | Northrop | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Simon Gilbert | Northrop | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Bailey Meerzo | Northrop | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Rashaad Moore | Northrop | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | James Jones | Northrop | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ben Arruza | Northrop | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jake Price | Northrop | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Davieun Berry | Northrop | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Matt Eastman | Snider | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Caleb Isley | Snider | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Drew McCrady | Snider | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Will Swartz | Snider | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kerry Perry | Snider | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Justin Kopke | Snider | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Johnell Hogue | Snider | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dalston Duff | Snider | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tavers Brown | Snider | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Darius Morgan | Snider | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Damari Meriwether | Snider | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Everett Merritt | South Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | DaMarque Perkins | South Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Corey Hannah | South Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Colton Threats | South Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mikale Stevenson | South Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brandon Eldridge | South Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tahj Alford | South Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Omar Jackson | South Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gerald Little | South Side | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aarik Adams | Wayne | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aamani Wright-Thompson | Wayne | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Latrell Lapsley | Wayne | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Calvin Mitchell | Wayne | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brandon Young | Wayne | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | John Allen | Wayne | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Devonair Kelsaw | Wayne | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | William Rowles | Wayne | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tristan Pernell | Wayne | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Keyshawn Fields | Wayne | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Sean Weideman | Wayne | ||
| 2017 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Camry Greer | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Camdyn Childers | Carroll | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Kamari Anderson-Drew | Concordia | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Craig Young | Wayne | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Joe Tippman | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Randy Holtz | Snider | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Joe Henry | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Will Swartz | Snider | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Alex Kolkman | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Norm Knapke | Bishop Luers | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Jordan Presley | Bishop Luers | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Alex Holliday-Robinson | North Side | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | A'Nyis Lockett | Snider | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | At Large | TJ Tippmann | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Carter Drake | Bishop Luers | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | John Paul Filler | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Liam Fletcher | Concordia | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Tavareon Scott | Snider | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jordan Watercutter | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Will Derrick | Bishop Luers | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Gianini Belizaire | Snider | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Darius Alexander | Wayne | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Tavhon McGarry | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Camden Rogers | Homestead | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Tahj Alford | South Side | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Tristan Pernell | Wayne | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Cam Shannon | Homestead | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Justin Gaston | Bishop Luers | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Ethan Hoover | Snider | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Drevyon Walton | Wayne | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Griffin Little | Homestead | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Davieun Berry | Northrop | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Tight End | Simon Dellinger | Snider | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Porter Haught | Homestead | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Latrell Lapsley | Wayne | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Will Derrick | Bishop Luers | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Arvonta Taylor | North Side | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Center | Orion Chenery | Carroll | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Gaven Vogt | Carroll | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Rhett Saylor | Carroll | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Jeremiah Green | Northrop | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Keshaun Fields | Wayne | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Trevor Horton | Carroll | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Braden West | North Side | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Terell Griffin | Carroll | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Xavier Ellington | Wayne | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Tristan Chambers | Concordia | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Vinnie Fiacable | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Micah Fretz | Carroll | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Michael Fairfield | Concordia | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Hayden Ellinger | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Allen Jackson | Bishop Luers | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Sean Weideman | Wayne | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Lincoln Lantz | Carroll | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Sam Obergell | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Theo Redmond | North Side | |
| 2018 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Omar Jackson | South Side | |
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Griffin Eifert | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Vinnie Tippmann | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nick Hosier | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Devon Tippman | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Michael Garrett | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jared Lee | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Charlie Howe | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Camari Harris | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nick Birkmeier | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Josh Dippold | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gabe Hendricks | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jack Sweeney | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Janarion Moore | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Collin Beeks | Carroll | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nathan Harrah | Carroll | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Edmond Johnson | Carroll | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cobey Malcom | Carroll | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Edward Bransfield | Carroll | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Layton Mitchell | Carroll | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Larry Sible | Carroll | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | We Stephens | Carroll | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ray Vollmer | Carroll | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Max Green | Carroll | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ben Henschen | Concordia | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jake Byrd | Concordia | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nick Craddock | Concordia | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tyler Grossman | Concordia | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Trevin Talor | Homestead | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aaron Harris | Homestead | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Christian Zahki | Homestead | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Landon Clark | North Side | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Reggie Telemaque | North Side | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Quincy Moore | North Side | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jalen Harris | North Side | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Auntral Franklin | North Side | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nick Price | Northrop | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brad Poiry | Northrop | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Bailey Meerzo | Northrop | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nigel Robertson | Northrop | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | James Jones | Northrop | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Young | Northrop | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Qualen Pettus | Northrop | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Antoine Scott | Northrop | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Rashawn Vaughn | Northrop | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Amarion Green | Northrop | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Elijah Maxwell | Snider | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Alonzo Derrick | Snider | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Bryson Reinig | Snider | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nick Pezley | Snider | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Luke Owens | Snider | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jalen Wiggins | Snider | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jon Barnes | Snider | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jayshaun Underwood | Snider | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Josue Sotero | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Caldijuan Mitchell | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cam Webb | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ronald Elliott | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aric Winborn | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cameron Chambers | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Simon Twiss | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brandan Young | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Devonair Kelsaw | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ja'Shawn Wilson | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Arik Adams | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cam Johnson | Wayne | ||
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Ryan Schlechty | Senior | Jay County |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Jack Stuckey | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Nick Miller | Sophomore | South Adams |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Jashawn Berlanga | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Levi Boots | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Justin Burnham | Junior | Heritage |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Dane Casselman | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Brady Girod | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | James Arnold | Sophomore | South Adams |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Parker Grimes | Senior | Jay County |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Everett Johnson | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Logan Macklin | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Bailea Sprunger | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Punter | Parker Bates | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Andre Hughes | Senior | South Adams |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Blake Kizer | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Jake McCullough | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Isaac Meyer | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Jalen Hammond | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Evan Kitt | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Michael Schlechty | Senior | Jay County |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Sebastian Speith | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Grady Sprunger | Junior | South Adams |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Parker Bates | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Drake Deitsch | Senior | South Adams |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Michael Scheumann | Senior | Heritage |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Grant Besser | Senior | South Adams |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Drew Stutzman | Sophomore | South Adams |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Trevor Wallace | Junior | Woodlan |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Tight End | Will Hamilton | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Tyler Burnham | Senior | Heritage |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Spenser Clark | Senior | South Adams |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Jacob Gerbers | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Monty Hill | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Braden Schrieber | Senior | Southern Wells |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Ben Reidy | Junior | Woodlan |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Hunter Bradtmeuller | Senior | Heritage |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Coleman Beeks | Senior | Southern Wells |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Conner Sowers | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Kody Kinsey | Sophomore | Bluffton |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Lucas Cashdollar | Senior | Heritage |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Zach Cummins | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Sam Lavy | Senior | Jay County |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Ben Voirol | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Keegan Jones | Junior | Woodlan |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Christian Summersett | Sophomore | South Adams |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Mikel Sutton | Senior | Southern Wells |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Charlie Woenker | Senior | Heritage |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Landon Grimes | Sophomore | Jay County |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Cody Mittlestedt | Sophomore | Bluffton |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Chase Peterson | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Colton Yergler | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Kentrel Thomas | Senior | New Haven |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Aaron Lehrman | Senior | Bellmont |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Peyton Wall | Junior | Leo |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Tight End | Jacob Bolt | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Damon Kaylor | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Liam Hesting | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Tylar Pomeroy | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Tom Busch | Junior | Leo |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Center | Arland Coolman | Senior | Leo |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Quarterback | Tim Jordan | Senior | New Haven |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Running Back | Kaiden Harshberger | Senior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Running Back | Alex Wertman | Senior | Leo |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Kicker | Aiden Hosler | Junior | Huntington North |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Punter | Evan Snider | Sophomore | DeKalb |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Specialist | Peyton Wall | Junior | Leo |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive End | Spencer Pattee | Senior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive End | Lukaas Roller | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jayden Elwood | Senior | Leo |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Leyth Al-Mohammedawi | Junior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Landon Miller | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | GT Baker | Junior | Leo |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Jon Bell | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Jacob VanGorder | Sophomore | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Safety | Aidan Friedel | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Safety | Eli Riley | Sophomore | Norwell |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Cornerback | Carter Smith | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Cornerback | Hayden Jones | Junior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Michael Sievers | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Deven Newcomb | Junior | Huntington North |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Noah Macklin | Senior | Bellmont |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Tight End | Blake Swygart | Senior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Kyle Miazga | Senior | Leo |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Alex Manns | Junior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Donald Miller | Junior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Nick Waters | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Center | Hoyt Stafford | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Quarterback | AJ Restivo | Senior | Leo |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Running Back | Jacob Wigent | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Running Back | Stephen Owens | Senior | New Haven |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Kicker | Davis Snyder | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Punter | Jacob Bolt | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Josh Grigsby | Junior | New Haven |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Curtis Winebrenner | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Jase Griffith | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Jack Curtless | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Jackson Herber | Senior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Charlie Agnew | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Colin Mills | Senior | Bellmont |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Jacob Wigent | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Safety | Bailey Parker | Junior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Safety | Garrison Brege | Senior | Norwell |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Cornerback | Jadon Hannie | Senior | Leo |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Cornerback | NiJae Fields-Lewis | Junior | New Haven |
| 2018 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Specialist | Mayson Wallen | Senior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Tight End | Landon Geiger | Senior | Norwell |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Gage Ernsberger | Junior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Garrison Brege | Senior | Norwell |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Levi Leidig | Senior | Norwell |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Grant Scheumann | Senior | Norwell |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Josh Grigsby | Junior | New Haven |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Guard | Damian Miller | Senior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Guard | Jack Curless | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Center | Jordan Slayton | Senior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Quarterback | Bailey Parker | Junior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Running Back | Tanner Jack | Sophomore | DeKalb |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Running Back | Logan Hippensteel | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Cale Gray | Junior | Norwell |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Drew Rethlake | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive Tackle | Gavin Hieber | Senior | Leo |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive Tackle | Sam Hanshew | Senior | New Haven |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Caden Friedt | Junior | Bellmont |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Tanner Martz | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Brock Eltzroth | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Safety | Mayson Wallen | Senior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Cornerback | Deven Newcomb | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Cornerback | Peyton Stout | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Kicker | Kai Zacharias | Sophomore | DeKalb |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Punter | Joe Painter | Junior | East Noble |
| 2018 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Specialist | TJ Bedwell | Sophomore | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Alonzo Derrick | Senior | Snider |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Jake Archbold | Senior | Homestead |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Griffin Little | Senior | Homestead |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Randy Holtz | Senior | Snider |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Luke Wiginton | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Joe Henry | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Brady Parker | Junior | Homestead |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Robert McCrory | Senior | Homestead |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Luke Goode | junior | Homestead |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Braeden Hardwick | junior | Homestead |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Alex Holliday-Robinson | Senior | North Side |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Keshaun Fields | Senior | Wayne |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Lenny Bennett | Senior | Snider |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Trevor Horton | Senior | Carroll |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Trevor Hapner | Sophomore | South Side |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Theo Redmond | Senior | North Side |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Reggie Blackmon | Senior | Wayne |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Jalen Wiggins | Senior | Snider |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Gianini Belizaire | Senior | Snider |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Larry Sible | Senior | Carroll |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Maxwell Burney | Junior | South Side |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Cam Rogers | Senior | Homestead |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Devon Tippmann | Junior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Luke Palmer | Junior | Homestead |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Hunter Mertz | Junior | Carroll |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Kameron Trotter | Senior | Snider |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Jayshawn Underwood | Senior | Snider |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Patrick Finley | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Antoine Scott | Senior | Northrop |
| 2019 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Ray Vollmer | Senior | Carroll |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Jalen Vanderbosch | Senior | Concordia |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Layton Mitchell | Senior | Carroll |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Tight End | Eddie, Bransfield | Junior | Carroll |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Reeve Muncie | Junior | Carroll |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Owen Hire | Junior | Homestead |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Brandon Brundige | Junior | North Side |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Simon Twiss | Senior | Wayne |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Center | Orion Chenery | Senior | Carroll |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Jon Barnes Jr. | Senior | Snider |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Amir Drew | Junior | Concordia |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Jeremiah Green | Senior | Northrop |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Gunnar Fry | Senior | Homestead |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Nigel Robertson | Senior | Northrop |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Wes Stephens | Senior | Carroll |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Jordan Watercutter | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Vinnie Fiacable | Junior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Will Derrick | Senior | Bishop Luers |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Lashon Miller | Junior | North Side |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Hayden Ellinger | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Nick Birkmeier | Senior | Bishop Luers |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Matthew Ottenweller | Senior | Carroll |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Jalen Harris | Senior | North Side |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Lincoln Lantz | Senior | Carroll |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Te’Noah Ridley | Senior | Northrop |
| 2019 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Griffin Eifert | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Patrick O’Keefe | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Alex Fosnaugh | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nolan Fischer | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Josh Scrogham | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brenden Lytle | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Louis Tippmann | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Patrick Finley | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Joseph Bulanda | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Michael Ledo Jr. | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Owen Sharp | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gage Renbarger | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Lucas Krohn | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Howie Steele | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Callan Stauffer | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Alex Workman | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cam Hedgecock | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jamic Johnson | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ben Rectanus | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ramon Anderson | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | C.J. Hale | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Drake Carter | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mason Englert | Carroll | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kyler Bills | Carroll | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jeffrey Becker | Carroll | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aaron Jacquay | Carroll | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Craig McGinnis | Carroll | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cade Dinan | Carroll | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tucker Steely | Carroll | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cooper Harris | Concordia | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Sam Hudson | Concordia | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kam Vanderbosch | Concordia | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kam Johnson | Concordia | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brandon Davis | Concordia | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tyler Grossman | Concordia | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jared Kistler | Homestead | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Matt Miller | Homestead | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nik Martin | Homestead | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cole Etchison | Homestead | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Morgan Lamon | Homestead | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ryan Burton | Homestead | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Donnovan Leonard | Homestead | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Vaughn Crews | Northrop | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Qualen Pettus | Northrop | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Adrian Sewell | Northrop | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | TaQuan White | Northrop | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Damarius Cowen | Northrop | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tarik Bajgoric | Northrop | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jose Reducindo | Northrop | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Young | Northrop | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Darrius Sanders | Northrop | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jacob Lambert | North Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aspen Pippert-Board | North Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Duce Taylor | North Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Turner | North Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | T.Q. Redmond | North Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Davonte Rogers | North Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Auntral Franklin | North Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aerion McCarter | North Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jermaine Wells | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dillon Duff | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Andrew Sims | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nic Myles | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Chris Arita | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | D.J. Moore | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kyler Davis | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cameron Miller | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nick Pezley | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tavian Rucklos | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Domanick Moon | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Caivon Spencer | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Isaiah Maxwell | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brock Widman | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tavarious Easley-Jones | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Donavin Eley | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Trent Rider | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Zach Tyndall | Snider | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Davonte Alford | South Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Fred Starks | South Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jeremiah Powell | South Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jaylen Lattimore | South Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Preston McElroy | South Side | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cam Webb | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Caldijaun Mitchell | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Matt Spriggs | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Authur Mhoon | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ronald Elliot | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cam Toles | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Shawn Collins | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kaysan Jones | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aidan Meek | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Desmond Davis | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ky’Ren Johnson | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ebon Person | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mehki Lee | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nate Moore | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ethan Dumas | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Antjuan Schneider | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Andrew Kennedy | Wayne | ||
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Drew Stutzman | Junior | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Kain Thornton | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Nick Miller | Junior | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Trevor Wallace | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Charlie Brunswick | Senior | Jay County |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Justin Burnham | Senior | Heritage |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Corbin Hirschy | Sophomore | Adams Central |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Carter Lewis | Junior | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Ryan Thompson | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | James Arnold | Junior | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Christian Summerset | Junior | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Cody Mittlestedt | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Athlete | Jed Perry | Senior | Southern Wells |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Kody Kinsey | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Punter | Trevor Wallace | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Joseph Collier | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Austin Gorney | Junior | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Jaden Keller | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Ben Voirol | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Cam Coleman | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Blake Heyerly | Sophomore | Adams Central |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Keegan Jones | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Grady Sprunger | Senior | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Nic Stuber | Senior | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Dalton Gerber | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Dallas Schwaller | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Aiden Wanner | Sophomore | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | David Bischoff | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Joe Reidy | Sophomore | Woodlan |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Tight End | Hunter Teichman | Senior | Heritage |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Caleb Augsberger | Senior | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Beau Brooks | Sophomore | Woodlan |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Paul Faurote | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Bryon Hernandez | Junior | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Orion King | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Clay Riddle | Senior | Heritage |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Josh Smith | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Hayden Nern | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Bailey Cox | Junior | Jay County |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Jacob Roemer | Freshman | Woodlan |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Aiden Wanner | Sophomore | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Nick Miller | Junior | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Braden Baumer | Senior | South Adams |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Kiel Eldridge | Sophomore | Heritage |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Lukas Hunt | Sophomore | Bluffton |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Chance Jacobs | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Kreigh Roush | Senior | Southern Wells |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Dan Herschberger | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Rylee Huftel | Junior | Jay County |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Reece Johnston | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Gage Pritchard | Junior | Heritage |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Alex Currie | Sophomore | Adams Central |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Quinn Faulkner | Sophomore | Jay County |
| 2019 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | William Fletcher | Senior | Southern Wells |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Jamar Hutchins | Senior | New Haven |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Hayden Jones | Senior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Michael Sievers | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Tight End | D.J. Allen | Sophomore | Leo |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Alex Manns | Senior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Tom Busch | Senior | Leo |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Tylar Pomeroy | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Landen Livingston | Sophomore | Leo |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | John Hinen | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Center | Joe Colbert | Senior | Norwell |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Quarterback | Bailey Parker | Senior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Running Back | Peyton Wall | Senior | Leo |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Running Back | Landon Miller | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Kicker | Aidan Hosler | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Punter | Cole Schubpach | Junior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Punter | Carson McCauley | Junior | Leo |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Specialist | Nijae Fields-Lewis | Senior | New Haven |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive End | Trey Ritchie | Senior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive End | Mason Sheron | Sophomore | Leo |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Landin Markins | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Leyth Al-Mohammedawi | Senior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | GT Baker | Senior | Leo |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Joel Rinkenberger | Junior | Norwell |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Gavin James | Senior | Leo |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Jacob Van Gorder | Junior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Safety | T.J. Bedwell | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Safety | Eli Riley | Junior | Norwell |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Cornerback | Nijae Fields-Lewis | Senior | New Haven |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Cornerback | Damien Gudakunst | Junior | Leo |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Cameron Livingston | Senior | Leo |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Gage Ernsberger | Senior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Easton Rhodes | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Tight End | Brett Christian | Sophomore | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Josh Grigsby | Senior | New Haven |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Trestan Kern | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Noah Schooley | Senior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Nate Ulman | Senior | Bellmont |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Greg Bolt | Sophomore | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Evan Eschbach | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Running Back | Tanner Jack | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Running Back | Justin Marcellus | Junior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Punter | Joe Painter | Senior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Jase Griffith | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Caden Conley | Senior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Ethan Brown | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Sidney Bassett | Junior | New Haven |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Tanner Martz | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Cole Schubpach | Junior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | D’Andre Wright | Junior | New Haven |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Treyton Lomont | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Safety | Rowan Zolman | Sophomore | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Safety | Lamar Hutchins | Senior | New Haven |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Cornerback | Brooks Miller | Senior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Specialist | T.J. Bedwell | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Tight End | Evan Snider | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Peyton McHale | Senior | Leo |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Kieran Gilles | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Lane Woodson | Junior | New Haven |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Chris Hood | Sophomore | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Guard | Hoyt Stafford | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Guard | Donny Miller | Senior | East Noble |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Running Back | Max Ringger | Junior | Norwell |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Brooks Longenbaugh | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Cale Gray | Senior | Norwell |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Isaac Carswell | Sophomore | New Haven |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Dom Blevins | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Trevor Reed | Senior | New Haven |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Michael O’Brien | Junior | Leo |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Safety | Jackson Holzinger | Junior | Huntington North |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Safety | Ryan Sheets | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Kicker | Garrett Klefeker | Sophomore | Columbia City |
| 2019 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Specialist | Mason DeHoff | Senior | Norwell |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Josh Gross | West Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Nolin Sharick | Fairfield | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Gage King | Angola | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Logan Sumowski | West Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Lucas Baker | West Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Peyton Hendrix | Fairfield | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Cole Bergman | Garrett | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Jaren Berning | Garrett | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Ross Holman | Angola | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Quarterback | Kyle Mawhorter | West Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Running Back | Brandon Pruitt | West Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Running Back | Antonio Luevanos | Angola | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Kicker | Zak Klopfenstein | Garrett | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Punter | Jaron Fry | Lakeland | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | At-Large | Colton Isaacs | Lakeland | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Braxton Pruitt | West Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Jeramyah James | West Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Lincoln Ott | Lakeland | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Nolan Hathaway | Garrett | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Kyle Trick | Angola | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Raven Slone | West Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Carson Abramson | Fairfield | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Clayton Fielden | Garrett | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Chase Soulliere | Angola | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Kyler Brown | West Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Kenny Walker | lakeland | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Ryan Brandt | Angola | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | 1st Team | At-Large | Seth VanWagner | Garrett | |
| 2019 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Cory Lants | Fairfield | ||
| 2019 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Camryn Holbrook | lakeland | ||
| 2019 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Kraig Smith | Garrett | ||
| 2019 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Rocky Slone | West Noble | ||
| 2019 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Miguel Delapaz | Lakeland | ||
| 2019 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Mateo Fuentes | Garrett | ||
| 2019 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | John Ortiz | Fairfield | ||
| 2019 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Colton Fisher | Fairfield | ||
| 2019 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Nathan Grossman | Lakeland | ||
| 2019 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Ethan Harter | Garrett | ||
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Wade Miller | Eastside | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Dylan Bredemeyer | Eastside | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Ethan Hoover | Prairie Heights | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Brenton Whiteacre | Central Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Jon Armstrong | Fremont | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Dustin Barkley | Churubusco | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Chase Leeper | Eastside | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Troy Kessler | Eastside | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Quarterback | Laban Davis | Eastside | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Running Back | Jake Fulk | Churubusco | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Running Back | Ethan Farnsworth | Eastside | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Kicker | Jaiden Baker | Eastside | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Punter | Sawyer Yoder | Central Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | At-Large | Kameron Colclasure | Fremont | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Isaac Tarney | Prairie Heights | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Reese Wicker | Churubusco | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Hunter Bianski | Churubusco | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Hayden Gardner | Eastside | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Austin McCullough | Central Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Case Lemper | Churubusco | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Carson Evers | Eastside | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Lane Cleckner | Eastside | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Sam Wood | Churubusco | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Gage Kelly | Churubusco | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Lane Burns | Eastside | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | 1st Team | At-Large | Sam Levitz | Central Noble | |
| 2019 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Blake Trostel | Churubusco | ||
| 2019 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Phoenix Smyth | Eastside | ||
| 2019 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Mike Geiger | Eastside | ||
| 2019 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Matt Jacobs | Eastside | ||
| 2019 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Isaiah Fuentes | Eastside | ||
| 2019 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Karson Meeks | Fremont | ||
| 2019 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Logan Brace | Fremont | ||
| 2019 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Carson Flynn | Fremont | ||
| 2019 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Jaden Zuccolotto | Fremont | ||
| 2019 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Dylan Parsons | Fremont | ||
| 2019 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | R.J. Dilbone | Fremont | ||
| 2019 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Drew Brosey | Fremont | ||
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Mason Englert | Senior | Carroll |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Nate Anderson | Junior | Homestead |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Ethan Chambers | Senior | Homestead |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Vinny Fiacable | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tackle | Reeve Muncie | Senior | Carroll |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Brady Parker | Senior | Homestead |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Guard | Aspen Pippert-Board | Senior | North Side |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Owen Hire | Senior | Homestead |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Duce Taylor | Senior | North Side |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Jeffrey Becker | Junior | Carroll |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Damarius Cowen | Senior | Northrop |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Ja'Suan Lambert | Senior | North Side |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Braeden Hardwick | Senior | Homestead |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Joe Bulanda | Junior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Carter Dixon | Junior | Homestead |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Isaac Parrish | Senior | Homestead |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Trevor Hapner | Junior | South Side |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Ison Robinson | Senior | Snider |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jacob Lambert | Senior | North Side |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jack Knight | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Devon Tippmann | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Luke Palmer | Senior | Homestead |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Hunter Mertz | Senior | Carroll |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Domanick Moon | Junior | Snider |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Tavarious Easley-Jones | Senior | Snider |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Brayden Payne | Junior | Concordia |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Arieon McCarter | Senior | North Side |
| 2020 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Callan Stauffer | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Jordan Turner | Junior | North Side |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Rocco Ciocca | Junior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Tight End | Jack Tippman | Junior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Tackle | Jaden Abouhalkah | Junior | Homestead |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Tackle | Jose Reducindo | Senior | Northrop |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Guard | Kyler Bills | Senior | Carroll |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Guard | Jajuan Hill | Senior | Northrop |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Center | Joe Fabini | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Evan Ormsby | Senior | Homestead |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Chris Thomas | Senior | Wayne |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Tyrese Brown | Junior | Snider |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Amir Drew | Senior | Concordia |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Sebastian Lopez | Sophomore | Carroll |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Simon Garrett | Junior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Reece Thomas | Senior | Snider |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Julante Hinton | Freshman | Northrop |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Logan Nahrwold | Senior | Concorida |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Ethan Klingler | Senior | Carroll |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Matt Miller | Junior | Homestead |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | John Michael Fabini | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Cooper Harris | Senior | Concordia |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Lah-Shon Miller | Senior | North Side |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Cole Etchison | Senior | Homestead |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Javonte Malone | Senior | South Side |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Sir Hale | Junior | Bishop Luers |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Kam Vanderbosch | Senior | Concordia |
| 2020 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Kam Johnson | Senior | Concordia |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Quarterback | Brenden Lytle | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Henry O'Keefe | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Colin Vance | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Adam Lee | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Gavin Groves | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Tackle | Owen Levi | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Sam Pesa | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Matthew Jimenez | Bishop Dwenger | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Quarterback | Carson Clark | Bishop Luers | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Brody Glenn | Bishop Luers | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Nick Thompson | Bishop Luers | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Menson Krashaun | Bishop Luers | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | George Buday | Bishop Luers | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Center | Ben Rectanus | Bishop Luers | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Foster Johnson | Bishop Luers | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Nelson Knapke | Bishop Luers | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Tackle | Da'Von Doughty | Bishop Luers | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Mason Daring | Bishop Luers | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Krashaun Menson | Bishop Luers | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Jameson Coverston | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Cade Dinan | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Tucker Steely | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Jorge Valdes | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Craig McGinnis | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Center | Daniel Riecke | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Aaron Jacquay | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Liam Ottenweller | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Boden Hite | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Running Back | Aiden Lazoff | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Running Back | Luke Carmody | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Max Malcolm | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Guard | Tyler Wiersema | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Cooper Rudolph | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kicker | Evan Jester | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Aaron Stewart | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Ethan Beaupre' | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Mark Murray | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Cam Hedgecock | Carroll | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Tyler Grossman | Concordia | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Sam Hudson | Concordia | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Matt Goeglein | Concordia | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Larry Schoenefeld | Concordia | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Jared Kistler | Homestead | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Isaac Barkes | Homestead | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Desmond Smith | Homestead | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Ryan Burton | Homestead | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Carter Cronenwett | Homestead | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Nicholas Schweizer | Homestead | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Guard | Sean Rice | Homestead | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Andrew Bear | Homestead | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Brauntae Johnson | North Side | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Adrian Sewell | North Side | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Ronald Collins III | North Side | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Tackle | Dazzman Mckenzie | North Side | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Center | Brandon Brundige | North Side | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Brashawn Bassett | North Side | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Darrius Sanders | Northrop | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | CJ Davis | Northrop | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Center | Devin McCalla | Northrop | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Kareem Freeman | Northrop | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Davohn Godsey | Northrop | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Jayden Schmenk | Northrop | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Sebastian McCormick | Northrop | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Brayden Mudrack | Northrop | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Jacob Smith | Northrop | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Michael Bird | Northrop | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Guard | Damon Baney | Northrop | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Isaiah Maxwell | Snider | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Tre Hurst | Snider | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tight End | Carter Wortman | Snider | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kicker | Trent Rider | Snider | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Markell Keal | Snider | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tight End | DJ Moore | Snider | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Tackle | Cameron Myles | Snider | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Jonathon McCullough | Snider | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Davonte Williams | South Side | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Marcus White-Allen | South Side | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tight End | Ashton Johnson | South Side | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Auther Mhoon | Wayne | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Julian Keeler | Wayne | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Guard | Cldijuan Mitchell | Wayne | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Christian Flannigan | Wayne | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Cam Toles | Wayne | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Running Back | Shawn Collins | Wayne | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Offensive Guard | Andrew Kennedy | Wayne | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Center | Mekhi Lee | Wayne | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tight End | Jamari Tabb | Wayne | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Ebon Person | Wayne | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Tackle | Giani Lagrone | Wayne | |
| 2020 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive Back | Avant Rogers | Wayne | |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Robert Malcolm | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Drew Stutzman | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Trey Schoch | Junior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Nick Miller | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Corbin Hirschy | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Jacob Landis | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Clay Riddle | Senior | Heritage |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Bryan Hernandez | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Carter Lewis | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | James Arnold | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Christian Summerset | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Cody Mittlestedt | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Gage Pritchard | Senior | Heritage |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Kody Kinsey | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Punter | Sheldon Eley | Senior | Jay County |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Joseph Collier | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Cameron Farmer | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Bailey Cox | Senior | Jay County |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Austin Gorney | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Blake Heyerly | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Kaine Moore | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Rylan Whitacre | Sophomore | Heritage |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Jacob Plattner | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Alex Currie | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Beau Bosler | Senior | Heritage |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Aidan Wanner | Junior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Brandon Bixler | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Alec Reiff | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Deontae Cobbins | Senior | Heritage |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Tight End | Brayson Yergler | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Cody Lautzenheiser | Sophomore | Adams Central |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Wyatt Bergman | Junior | Jay County |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Brayden Gilbert | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Beau Brooks | Junior | Woodlan |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Carlos Taylor | Junior | Woodlan |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Hayden Nern | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Jacob Snyder | Sophomore | Woodlan |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Nick Neuenschwander | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | David Rogers-Potter | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Aidan Wanner | Junior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Nick Miller | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Garrett Pauley | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Timmy Davidson | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Dom Kahn | Senior | South Adams |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Isaac Manning | Junior | Woodlan |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Mason DeRoo | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Keegan Bluhm | Freshman | Adams Central |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Reece Johnston | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Rylee Huffel | Senior | Jay County |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Austin Snyder | Sophomore | Woodlan |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Gavin Cook | Sophomore | Adams Central |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Seth Bennett | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2020 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Ethan Vardaman | Sophomore | Woodlan |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | TJ Bedwell | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Lane Woodson | Senior | New Haven |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Rowan Zolman | Junior | East Noble |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Tight End | Isaiah Brege | Senior | Norwell |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Chris Hood | Junior | East Noble |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Quinn Dreiband | Senior | Norwell |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Landen Livingston, Leo, junior | Junior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Brody Bolyn | Sophomore | Norwell |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Center | Ethan Stetzel | Senior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Quarterback | Eli Riley | Senior | Norwell |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Running Back | Max Ringger | Senior | Norwell |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Running Back | Justin Marcellus | Senior | East Noble |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Kicker | Carson McCauley | Senior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Punter | Carson McCauley | Senior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive End | DJ Allen | Junior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive End | Trace Holliday | Junior | East Noble |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Zach Christianson | Junior | Norwell |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Ethan Stewart | Senior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Joel Rinkenberger | Senior | Norwell |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Dre Wright | Senior | New Haven |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Michael O’Brien | Senior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Jacob Van Gorder | Senior | East Noble |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Tanner Jackson | Junior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Safety | Rylan Crawford | Junior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Safety | Bo Morgan | Junior | Norwell |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Cornerback | Luke Graft | Sophomore | Norwell |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Cornerback | Damien Gudakunst | Senior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Specialist | Tanner Jack | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Nick Munson | Junior | East Noble |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Tanner Jack | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Tight End | Brett Christian | Junior | East Noble |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Cole Mosier | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Tyson Conley | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Bryce Charles | Junior | East Noble |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Hunter Strack | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Center | Ian Clifford | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Greg Bolt | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Running Back | Kaeden Miller | Junior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Running Back | Aden Dennis | Junior | Huntington North |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Kicker | Aden Dennis | Junior | Huntington North |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Punter | Cole Schupbach | Senior | East Noble |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Kaden Ward | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Matthew Bobay | Senior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Raymond Britt | Senior | New Haven |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | A’vyonn Creech | Junior | New Haven |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Dallen Wirtz | Senior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Aiden Rabb | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Treyton Lomont | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Keagan Landrum | Junior | Huntington North |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Safety | Ryan Sheets | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Safety | Jackson Holzinger | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Cornerback | Garrett Geiger | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Cornerback | Nathaniel Summers | Junior | East Noble |
| 2020 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Specialist | TJ Bedwell | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Tight End | Bailey Landrum | Junior | Huntington North |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Jalen Carpenter | Senior | New Haven |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Wide Reciever | Hunter Herron | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Jon Louden | Senior | New Haven |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Connor Cannon | Junior | New Haven |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Center | Mason Moore | Senior | New Haven |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Quarterback | Jakar Williams | Junior | New Haven |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Running Back | Curtis Martin | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Running Back | Jarrell Jackson | Junior | New Haven |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Matthew Bobay | Senior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Trestan Kern | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive Tackle | Landin Markins | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Joe Laughlin | Senior | Bellmont |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Carson Hoeppner | Junior | Leo |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Jameron Hagler | Senior | New Haven |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Cornerback | Jon Colbert | Sophomore | Norwell |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Safety | Trevion Thomas | Junior | new Haven |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Safety | Nate Williams | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Kicker | Christian Sanchez | Senior | East Noble |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Punter | Evan Snider | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2020 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Specialist | Dre Wright | Senior | New Haven |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Colton Fisher | Fairfield | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Braedeon Helms | Fairfield | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Gage King | Angola | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Lucas Baker | West Noble | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Coy Brames | Angola | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Jaxson Nodine | Garrett | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Mike Stout | Fairfield | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Grant Thacker | Fairfield | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Quarterback | Cory Lantz | Fairfield | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Running Back | Kolin Cope | Garrett | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Running Back | Quinn Kitson | Fairfield | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Kicker | Zak Klopfenstein | Garrett | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Punter | Jaron Fry | Lakeland | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | At-Large | Finley Hasselman | Angola | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Joel Barkey | Garrett | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Jason Massaro | Fairfield | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Braxton Pruitt | West Noble | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Brandon Villafuerte | Angola | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Bryce Alleshouse | Lakeland | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Carson Abramson | Fairfield | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Giovanni Tagliaferri | Angola | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Seth VanWagner | Garrett | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Colton Isaacs | Lakeland | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Trey Richards | Garrett | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Brock Short | Fairfield | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | 1st Team | At-Large | Tucker Hasselman | Angola | |
| 2020 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Miguel Delapaz | Lakeland | ||
| 2020 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Nathan Klinedinst | Fairfield | ||
| 2020 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Aadon Lytle | Garrett | ||
| 2020 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Brayden Short | Fairfield | ||
| 2020 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Zack Warfield | Garrett | ||
| 2020 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Mark William | Garrett | ||
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Trey Hearld | Central Noble | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Wade Miller | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Gavin Wallace | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Cody Melson | Prairie Heights | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Isiah Fuentes | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Matt Jacobs | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Jackson Wicker | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Jon Armstrong | Fremont | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Quarterback | Laban Davis | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Running Back | Matt Firestine | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Running Back | Carson Flynn | Fremont | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Kicker | Jaiden Baker | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Punter | Sawyer Yoder | Central Noble | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | At-Large | Kameron Colclasure | Fremont | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Hunter Bianski | Churubusco | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Hayden Gardner | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Phoenix Smyth | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Line | RJ Dilbone | Fremont | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Will Hoover | Central Noble | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Lane Cleckner | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Kyler Bibbee | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Brayton Gordon | Churubusco | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Nick Nondorf | Churubusco | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Lane Burns | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Carson Jacobs | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | 1st Team | At-Large | Dax Holman | Eastside | |
| 2020 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Jarrett Hawk | Central Noble | ||
| 2020 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Jaden Zuccolotto | Fremont | ||
| 2020 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Johnny Eck | Eastside | ||
| 2020 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Preston Diffendarfer | Central Noble | ||
| 2020 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Dylan Parsons | Fremont | ||
| 2020 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Logan Brace | Fremont | ||
| 2020 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Hunter Allen | Prairie Heights | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Brody Glenn | Senior | Bishop Luers |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Nate Anderson | Senior | Homestead |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Jameson Coverstone | Senior | Carroll |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Jayden Hill | Junior | Bishop Luers |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | DJ Moore | Senior | Snider |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Max Malcolm | Senior | Carroll |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Tyler Wiersema | Senior | Carroll |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Jaden Abouhalkah | Senior | Homestead |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | George Buday | Senior | Bishop Luers |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Carson Clark | Senior | Bishop Luers |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Jeff Becker | Senior | Carroll |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Tyrese Brown | Senior | Snider |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Lamarion Nelson | Junior | Wayne |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Sebastian Lopez | Junior | Carroll |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Kayden Libby-Callahan | Senior | North Side |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Markell Keal | Senior | Snider |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Nehemiah Young | Junior | Wayne |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jack Tippmann | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Jackson Christmon | Junior | Homestead |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Mitch Vargovich | Junior | North Side |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Dominick Moon | Senior | Snider |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Dylan Bennett | Senior | Carroll |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Tucker Steely | Senior | Carroll |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Isaiah Maxwell | Senior | Snider |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Nick Thompson | Junior | Bishop Luers |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Ethan Beaupre' | Senior | Carroll |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Brauntae Johnson | Sophomore | North Side |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | CJ Davis | Junior | Northrop |
| 2021 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Avant Rogers | Senior | Wayne |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Jordan Turner | Senior | North Side |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Rocco Ciocca | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Antwain Lake | Senior | Bishop Luers |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Tight End | Carter Wortman | Senior | Snider |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Nick Schweizer | Senior | Homestead |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Carmarion Craig | Junior | Concordia |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Brendan Mitchell | Senior | Bishop Luers |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Ashton Skarie | Junior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Center | Brandon Stuckey | Junior | Snider |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Luke Haupert | Junior | Snider |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Sir Hale | Senior | Bishop Luers |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | KJ Tippmann | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Nick Talamantez | Junior | Snider |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Dixon Carter | Senior | Homestead |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Aaron Jacquay | Senior | Carroll |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Julante Hinton | Sophomore | Northrop |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Matt Miller | Senior | Homestead |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Mark Murray | Senior | Carroll |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Mike King III | Junior | South Side |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Evan Linker | Senior | Bishop Luers |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Max Schiltz | Senior | Homestead |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Ebon Person | Senior | Homestead |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Cole Carey | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Rashawn Boone | Senior | Northrop |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Michael Dye | Junior | North Side |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Quincy Myatt | Senior | Snider |
| 2021 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Colin Vance | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Henry O'Keefe | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Stellan Ruston | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Joe Eddy | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Joe Bulanda | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Adam Lee | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gavin Groves | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Simon Garrett | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aziz Dixon | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Benji Tippmann | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tommy Witte | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Isaac Lehrman | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Joel Arntz | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ben Simcox | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | John Parapi | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Teddy Steele | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Christian Lozada | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Bohde Dickerson | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jaden Sykes | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nelson Knapke | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Davon Doughty | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Omare Bates | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Isaac Zay | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jackson McCullough | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | RJ Hogue | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Roel Pineda | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mickey Daring | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gio Jimenez | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | AJ Lazoff | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Hansen Haffner | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cooper Rudolph | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gabe Starks | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jake Rust | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Luke Carmody | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Justin Anderson | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jake Wilson | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Johnathon Scott | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ashton Pesetski | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Liam Ottenweller | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aaron Stewart | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Alex Smith | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Maddix Flaugh | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Braden Steely | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jorge Valdes | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Max Wiard | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Evan Jester | Carroll | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | James Rusher | Concordia | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Robert Johnson | Concordia | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Larry Schoenefeld | Concordia | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Eli Maddox | Concordia | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Chance Harris | Concordia | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gage Sparrow | Homestead | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Carter Hull - C | Homestead | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Payton Slaven | Homestead | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Carter Koob | Homestead | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Isaac Barkes | Homestead | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Eric Williamson | Homestead | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jayden Schmenk | Northrop | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jaylen Williams | Northrop | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jermaine Parker | Northrop | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Amarion Collins | Northrop | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Roosevelt Norfleet III | Northrop | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dane Kilby | Northrop | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Damon Baney | Northrop | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tavon Freeman | Northrop | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | David Hunter | Northrop | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jamarius Thomas | Northrop | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nick Dyke | Northrop | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Donovan Williams | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Terrell Coleman | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wes Troye | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ryan Collins | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Torrey Harmeyer | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Justin Engle | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Rodney Woods | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Bravon Bassett | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan King | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Da'Von Haney | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brashawn Bassett | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ashton Newsome | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Isaiah Simmons | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jamie Roy | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jontae Lambert | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Khristion Stalling | North Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Anthony Thomas | South Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Quincey English | South Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Adrain Macon | South Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Trevor Hapner | South Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jaylen Lattimore | South Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Marcus White Allen | South Side | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aiden Pelz | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Chevalier | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Caleb Hurt | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Lincoln Firks | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Lee | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Langston Leavell | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jacob Stetka | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Caiden Hurse | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kamari Juarez | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kedrell Billingsley | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | A'dorean Rogers | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Santiago Ortiz | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Lukas Rohrbacher | Snider | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Shawn Collins | Wayne | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Virgil Alexander | Wayne | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Marquette Derrick-Rowles | Wayne | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aiden Meek | Wayne | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cody Hatfield | Wayne | ||
| 2021 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Keaton Walker | Wayne | ||
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Chase Gibson | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Trey Schoch | Senior | South Adams |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Braysen Yergler | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Jackson Bearman | Junior | Heritage |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Cameron Farmer | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Bryan Girod | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Corbin Hirschy | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Thomas Murphy | Junior | South Adams |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Lukas Hunt | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Alex Currie | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Blake Heyerly | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Quinn Faulkner | Senior | Jay County |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Hunter Kongar | Junior | South Adams |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Punter | Fa Re Dal | Sophomore | Heritage |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Beau Brooks | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Jordan Hinshaw | Senior | South Adams |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Joe Reidy | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Zac Wurm | Sophomore | Adams Central |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Keegan Bluhm | Sophomore | Adams Central |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | John Ringger | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Mav Summersett | Junior | South Adams |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Rylan Whitacre | Junior | Heritage |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Gavin Cook | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | AJ Dull | Senior | South Adams |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Nick Neuenschwander | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Alec Reiff | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Ibrahim Williams | Sophomore | Heritage |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Tight End | Brady Beall | Junior | South Adams |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Isaiah Brumbaugh | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Howie Kaiser | Junior | Heritage |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Peyton Long | Sophomore | Southern Wells |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Clayton Trausch | Sophomore | South Adams |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Line | Bryce Wenk | Sophomore | Jay County |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Ryan Black | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Jake Snyder | Junior | Woodlan |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Austin Stephenson | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | AJ Wright | Senior | Southern Wells |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Braeden Hall | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Joe Reidy | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Johnny Cruz | Sophomore | Bluffton |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | DeJay Gerig | Junior | Woodlan |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Seth Mason | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Line | Case Myers | Senior | South Adams |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Jacov Kimpel | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Kaden Ridenour | Junior | Jay County |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Ryan Tester | Sophomore | Adams Central |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Dalton White | Junior | Heritage |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Carter Fleek | Freshman | Woodlan |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Landon Hicks | Sophomore | Heritage |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Josh Mosser | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2021 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Back | Qadon Ferrell | Senior | Jay County |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Rowan Zolman | Senior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Mylan Graham | Sophomore | New Haven |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Donnie Wiley | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Tight End | Rylan Crawford | Senior | Leo |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Chris Hood | Senior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Kyle Zeddis | Junior | Norwell |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Landen Livingston | Senior | Leo |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Brody Bolyn | Junior | Norwell |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Center | Sam Htoo | Senior | Leo |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Quarterback | Greg Bolt | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Running Back | Mason Sheron | Senior | Leo |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Running Back | Luke Graft | Junior | Norwell |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Kicker | Garrett Klefeker | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Punter | Rowan Zolman | Senior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive End | DJ Allen | Senior | Leo |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive End | Trace Holliday | Senior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Bryce Charles | Senior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Dylan Velez | Sophomore | Bellmont |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Isaac Carswell | Senior | New Haven |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Cam McCarver | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Ethan Crawford | Junior | Leo |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Nolan Rhoades | Senior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Safety | Jon Colbert | Junior | Norwell |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Safety | Nate Williams | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Cornerback | Nick Munson | Senior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Cornerback | Cade Shelton | Sophomore | Norwell |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Specialist | Kaeden Miller | Senior | Leo |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Logan Montoya | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Dillon Trout | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Tight End | Brett Christian | Senior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Tight End | Trey Bodenheimer | Sophomore | Norwell |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Collin Butler | Junior | Leo |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Cole Mosier | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Ian Clifford | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Truman Wirtz | Junior | Leo |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Center | Nathan Richards | Senior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Jakar Williams | Senior | New Haven |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Running Back | Kainon Carico | Senior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Running Back | Ethan Sievers | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Kicker | Nik Klein | Junior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Punter | Garrett Klefeker | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Easton Carnahan | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Nic Ley | Freshman | DeKalb |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Bailey Landrum | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Riley Tucker | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Drew Baker | Junior | Leo |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Ryan Elsten | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Josh Arntz | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Blake Haiflich | Senior | Norwell |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Safety | Quantri Sanders | Senior | New Haven |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Safety | Keagan Landrum | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Cornerback | Hunter Herron | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Cornerback | Kamari Clopton | Senior | New Haven |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Kicker | Nik Klein | Junior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Punter | Garrett Klefeker | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2021 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Specialist | Ethan Nickles | Senior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Tight End | Derek Overbay | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Connor Cannon | Senior | New Haven |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Tackle | Zack Leighty | Sophomore | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Guard | Avyonn Creech | Senior | New Haven |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Offensive Guard | Cole Mendez | Sophomore | Bellmont |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Center | Ayden Billiard | Sophomore | Norwell |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Quarterback | Tegan Irk | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Running Back | Carson Hoeppner | Senior | Leo |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Running Back | Kaeden Miller | Senior | Leo |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive Line | Guillermo Camarena | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive Line | Bryce Roop | Senior | Bellmont |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Landon Armstrong | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Chris Stewart | Sophomore | New Haven |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Jamison Rumple | Senior | Bellmont |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Mitch Snyder | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Cornerback | Dalton Stinson | Senior | East Noble |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Cornerback | Trevor Walker | Senior | Bellmont |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Kicker | Dylan Wilson | Sophomore | DeKalb |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Punter | Logan Wilson | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2021 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Specialist | Nate Williams | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Braedon Helms | Fairfield | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Trey Richards | Garrett | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Mark Burlew | Lakeland | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Dayton Lockwood | Fairfield | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Grant Thacker | Fairfield | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Jensen Miller | Lakeland | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Lucas Baker | West Noble | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive Line | Jaxson Nodine | Garrett | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Quarterback | Carter Kitson | Fairfield | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Running Back | Zack Beers | West Noble | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Running Back | John Estep | Fairfield | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Kicker | Julio Macias | West Noble | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Punter | Aaden Lytle | Garrett | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | At-Large | Finley Hasselman | Angola | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Brandon Villafuerte | Angola | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Jason Massaro | Fairfield | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Jack O’Connor | Garrett | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Quinlinn Raber | Lakeland | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Brock Berkey | Fairfield | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Carson Harter | Garrett | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Mark William | Garrett | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Carlos Espino | Lakeland | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Braxton Pruitt | West Noble | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Cohen Custer | Fairfield | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Owen Troyer | Lakeland | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Kolby Knox | West Noble | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | 1st Team | At-Large | Mathew William | Garrett | |
| 2021 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Ethan Miller | Angola | ||
| 2021 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Lukas Swager | Garrett | ||
| 2021 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Michael Slabaugh | Fairfield | ||
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Gavin Wallace | Eastside | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Carsen Jacobs | Eastside | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Preston Diffendarfer | Central Noble | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Kaleb Oliver | Churubusco | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Isaac Clay | Central Noble | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Isaiah Fuentes | Eastside | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Matt Jacobs | Eastside | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Center | Dane Sebert | Eastside | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Quarterback | Laban Davis | Eastside | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Running Back | Will Hoover | Central Noble | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Running Back | Nick Nondorf | Churubusco | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Kicker | Binyam Biddle | Eastside | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Punter | Riley Buroff | Churubusco | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | At-Large | Logan Brace | Fremont | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Hunter Bianski | Churubusco | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Bobby Davis | Eastside | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Brady Laub | Eastside | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Line | Hunter Allen | Prairie Heights | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Cullen Blake | Churubusco | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Dax Holman | Eastside | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Ashton Dunlap | Central Noble | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Cam Hall | Prairie Heights | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Johnny Eck | Eastside | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Dylan Bredemeyer | Eastside | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive Back | Logan Hawk | Central Noble | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | 1st Team | At-Large | Kameron Rinker | Churubusco | |
| 2021 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Jaden Daniels | Prairie Heights | ||
| 2021 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Wyatt Claxton | Fremont | ||
| 2021 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Brogan Blue | Fremont | ||
| 2021 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Tyler Shisler | Central Noble | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Brauntae Johnson | Junior | North Side |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Kamari Juarez | Senior | Snider |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Nick Thompson | Senior | Bishop Luers |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Grant Leeper | Senior | Homestead |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Mitch Vargovich | Senior | North Side |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Carmarion Craig | Senior | Concordia |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Aiden Hunley | Senior | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Jordan King | Junior | North Side |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Brandon Stuckey | Senior | Snider |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Jake Wilson | Junior | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Jimmy Sullivan | Sophomore | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Luke Haupert | Senior | Snider |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Jontae Lambert | Senior | North Side |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Lamarion Nelson | Senior | Wayne |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Sebastian Lopez | Senior | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Joseph Moran | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Davon Doughty | Senior | North Side |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Max Malone | Senior | Snider |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Da'Von Haney Jr. | Junior | North Side |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Kelso Will | Junior | Snider |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Khalon Kelsaw | Senior | Wayne |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Middle Linebacker | Lukas Rohrbacher | Junior | Snider |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Middle Linebacker | James Rusher | Senior | Concordia |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Outside Linebacker | Robert Pelkington | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Outside Linebacker | Justin Anderson | Junior | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Corner Back | Kedrell Billingsley | Senior | Snider |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Corner Back | Teddy Steele | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Safety | CJ Davis | Senior | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Safety | Jorge Valdes | Senior | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 1st Team | Safety | Braden Steely | Junior | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Ajani Washington | Junior | Concordia |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Cam Herschberger | Senior | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Jayden Morris | Senior | South Side |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Tight End | Lincoln Firks | Senior | Snider |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Eric Williamson | Senior | Homestead |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Ethan Dodson | Junior | Snider |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Chance Harris | Senior | Concordia |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Johnathan Scott | Junior | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Center | Khristion Stalling | Senior | North Side |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Center | Carter Werth | Senior | Homestead |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Bohde Dickerson | Senior | North Side |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Langston Leavell | Senior | Snider |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Nate Starks | Sophomore | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Nick Talamantez | Senior | Snider |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Roel Pineda | Senior | Bishop Luers |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Ashton Pesetski | Junior | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Grant Hayworth | Senior | Concordia |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Mickey Daring | Junior | Bishop Luers |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Nick Pelkington | Sophomore | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Tayoung Holley | Senior | North Side |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Middle Linebacker | Julante Hinton | Junior | Northrop |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Middle Linebacker | Max Wiard | Senior | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Outside Linebacker | Josh Masasu | Sophomore | North Side |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Outside Linebacker | Jacob Sharin | Sophomore | Wayne |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Corner Back | Michael Dye | Senior | North Side |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Corner Back | Michael Dierckman | Senior | Carroll |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Safety | Logan Brandon | Sophomore | Snider |
| 2022 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Safety | Jaylen Williams | Senior | Northrop |
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Sam Campbell | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Sam Trabel-Weir | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ethan Pflueger | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Stellan Ruston | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Preston Ross | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ashton Skarie | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Elijah Douge | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nate Reith | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Franklin Bader | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Carter Minix | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Christian Lozada | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Max Carey | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Trent Tippmann | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brayden McInturf | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tj Smith | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Sykes | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wesley Javins | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Charlie Stanski | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gio Jimenez | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | RJ Hogue | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kolin Jolas | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Zamarion Jackson | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cadell Wallace | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jackson McCullough | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Isaac Zay | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jaden Sykes | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cooper Rudolph | Carroll | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gabe Starks | Carroll | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jaydn Barcalow | Carroll | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kaden Swedzinski | Carroll | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Solomon Oduma | Carroll | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | William Jeffries | Carroll | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Carson Vogt | Carroll | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Hansen Haffner | Carroll | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jayden Hill | Carroll | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Caiden Abbs | Carroll | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Royce Jones | Carroll | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Eli Mattox | Concordia | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Landon Kaschinske | Concordia | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tyler Moher | Concordia | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Luke Giese | Homestead | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Nikko Stavretis | Homestead | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mason Auxier | Homestead | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brett Fuchs | Homestead | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jackson Bell | Homestead | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Peyton Slaven | Homestead | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kamden Johnson | Homestead | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jackson Christmon | Homestead | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gavin Weible | Homestead | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gavin Cozad | Homestead | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wyatt Little | Homestead | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Keone Bates | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Devion Woods | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Landen Hirsch | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kannga Vongphachanh | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mason Widmer | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ezekiel Cowherd | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Bryce Madison | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Matt Morgan | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jayden Schmenk | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | James Williams | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Riley Murphy | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Decorian Pittman | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tavon Freeman | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Micah Cowherd | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jakob Gump | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aaron Robinson | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Adrian Portee | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Josh Taylor | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | O'Marion Rogers | Northrop | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ean Coburn | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Demarrion Jones | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jago Espinosa | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jamari Pearson | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Aden White | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jaylen Eliis | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kaden Hurst | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jeremiah Adams | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jamie Roy | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brashawn Bassett | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tristen Newsome | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dylan Schible | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Bravon Bassett | North Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Isaiah Anderson | South Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jermaine Freemon | South Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Lonnie Hardy | South Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jeremy Irby | South Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Michael King | South Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Isaac Lee | South Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Adrian Macon | South Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Larrenz Tabron | South Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Eriyon Williams | South Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dantonio Wilson | South Side | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Amarrion Moore | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Adam Blakey | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Naveon Warren | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | KJ Eldridge | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jason Pierre-Louis | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Austin Ganaway | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | De'alcapone Veazy | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Anthony Hernandez | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Levi Overholser | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Donte Sanders | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jordan Lee | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | De'Marreia Stephens | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Zyon Greene | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Carter Wilson | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Uriah Buchanan | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Pau Lian | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Paul Hager | Snider | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ki'shawn Toles | Wayne | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Harrison Brooks | Wayne | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cody Hatfield | Wayne | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Harold Mack | Wayne | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Deonte Williams | Wayne | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kenyon Davis | Wayne | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Peyton Alt | Wayne | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mikelion Ragsdale | Wayne | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Darrion Alexander | Wayne | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cayden Rochford | Wayne | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Christian Trimble | Wayne | ||
| 2022 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kairoe Lloyd | Wayne | ||
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Quarterback | Tegan Irk | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Running back | Luke Graft | Senior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Running back | Ethan Sievers | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Tight end | Derek Overbay | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide receiver | Mylan Graham | Junior | New Haven |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide receiver | Stratton Fuller | Sophomore | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide receiver | Donnie Wiley | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Center | Joel Yager | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Guard | Brody Bolyn | Senior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Guard | Jack Maley | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Tackle | Collin Butler | Senior | Leo |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Tackle | Zack Leighty | Junior | East Noble |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive end | Trey Bodenheimer | Junior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive end | Brock Schott | Sophomore | Leo |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Dylan Velez | Junior | Bellmont |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Easton Brown | Senior | East Noble |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Dylan Krehl | Sophomore | East Noble |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Aydan Rusu | Senior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Josh Arntz | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Linebacker | Drew Ringger | Senior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Safety | Martin Smith | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Safety | Jon Colbert | Senior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Cornerback | Cade Shelton | Junior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Cornerback | Landin Hoeppner | Sophomore | Leo |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Kicker | Austin DeLeon | Junior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Punter | Brody Bolyn | Senior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Specialist | Tyson Reinbold | Junior | East Noble |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Colten Pieper | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Running back | Max Loeffler | Senior | Leo |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Running back | Noah Wagner | Junior | Huntington North |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Tight end | Peyton Shearer | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide receiver | Kline Neuenschwander | Senior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide receiver | Logan Schultz-Montoya | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide receiver | Kamden Zeisloft | Sophomore | Leo |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Center | Riley Stewart | Junior | Leo |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Guard | Truman Wirtz | Senior | Leo |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Guard | Nate Terry | Senior | East Noble |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Tackle | Kyle Zeddis | Senior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Tackle | AJ Spencer | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive end | Easton Carnahan | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive end | Dazhon Ware | Senior | New Haven |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Riley Tucker | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Liam Marzolf | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Alex Holcomb | Senior | Leo |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Dominic Chacon | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Ethan Crawford | Senior | Leo |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Brent Fuller | Junior | Leo |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Safety | Logan Hatton | Sophomore | East Noble |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Safety | Jay Mares | Senior | New Haven |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Cornerback | Caden Pettis | Junior | DeKalb |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Cornerback | Ian Stahl | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Kicker | Landon Urban | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Punter | Colten Pieper | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Specialist | James Getts | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Quarterback | Lleyton Bailey | Senior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Running back | Tyson Reinbold | Junior | East Noble |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Running back | Tre Bates | Junior | New Haven |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Tight end | Asher Chipchosky | Junior | Huntington North |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Wide receiver | Keegan Corbin | Junior | East Noble |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Center | Cole Mendez | Junior | Bellmont |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Guard | Ayden Billiard | Junior | Norwell |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Guard | Mason Knoch | Junior | New Haven |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Tackle | Wyatt Birch | Sophomore | DeKalb |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Tackle | Devin Krider | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive end | Sam Close | Senior | Huntington North |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive end | Nic Ley | Sophomore | DeKalb |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive Tackle | Guillermo Camarena | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive Tackle | Cameron Hyser | Senior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Korin Harris | Junior | New Haven |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Jason Teusch | Sophomore | Huntington North |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Linebacker | Graham Blythe | Sophomore | DeKalb |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Safety | Cohen Payne | Junior | Columbia City |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Safety | Job Hoffman | Junior | Bellmont |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Cornerback | Cristian Hatch | Junior | Bellmont |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Cornerback | AJ Ross | Sophomore | DeKalb |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Kicker | Jake Patton | Senior | Leo |
| 2022 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Punter | Tegan Irk | Senior | DeKalb |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Owen Wanner | Junior | South Adams |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Jake Snyder | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Running back | Keegan Bluhm | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Running back | Anthony Cruz | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Wide receiver | Patrick Hemmelgarn | Senior | Jay County |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Wide receiver | Silas Loshe | Senior | South Adams |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Tight end | Brady Beall | Senior | South Adams |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive line | Cody Lautzenheiser | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive line | Johnny Cruz | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive line | Jackson Bearman | Senior | Heritage |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive line | Howie Kaiser | Senior | Heritage |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Offensive line | Thomas Murphy | Senior | South Adams |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive line | Trevor Currie | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive line | Zac Wurm | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive line | Charlie Riddle | Sophomore | Heritage |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive line | Bryce Wenk | Junior | Jay County |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Ryan Black | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Ryan Tester | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Rylan Whitacre | Senior | Heritage |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Linebacker | Mav Summersett | Senior | South Adams |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive back | Gavin Cook | Senior | Adams Central |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive back | Ben Ramseyer | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive back | Landon Hicks | Junior | Heritage |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Defensive back | Carter Fleek | Sophomore | Woodlan |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Punter | Luke Meyer | Junior | Woodlan |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Moe Min Aung | Junior | Heritage |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Kobe Meyer | Junior | Heritage |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Running back | Kaden Ridenour | Senior | Jay County |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Running back | Drew Fleek | Sophomore | Woodlan |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Running back | Bryar Gearheart | Junior | Southern Wells |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Wide receiver | AJ Streveler | Freshman | Bluffton |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Wide receiver | Ibrahim Williams | Junior | Heritage |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Tight end | Tanner Whitman | Senior | Heritage |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive line | Braydon Moon | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive line | Sam Mechling | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive line | Joe Dodane | Senior | Heritage |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive line | Clayton Trausch | Junior | South Adams |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Offensive line | Austin Snyder | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive line | Lain Lengerich | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive line | Alex West | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive line | Logan Teichman | Junior | Heritage |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive line | Gavin Myers | Senior | South Adams |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Kayden King | Senior | Bluffton |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Lucas Straight | Sophomore | Jay County |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Conner Fear | Junior | South Adams |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Linebacker | Brayden Jackson | Junior | Southern Wells |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive back | Jack Hamilton | Junior | Adams Central |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive back | Andrew Hunt | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive back | Colton Bollenbacher | Junior | South Adams |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Defensive back | Braden Walter | Sophomore | Heritage |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Braxton Betancourt | Junior | Bluffton |
| 2022 | All ACAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Hunter Kongar | Senior | South Adams |
| 2022 | All ACAC | Honorable Mention | Defensive line | Jaxon Fleek | Senior | Woodlan |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Quarterback | Riley Buroff | Churubusco | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Running back | Wyatt Marks | Churubusco | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Running back | Dax Holman | Eastside | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Wide receiver | Gavin Hulsenbeck | Churubusco | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Wide receiver | Brogan Blue | Fremont | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Wide receiver | Jaden Daniels | Prairie Heights | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive line | Bentley Kilgore | Churubusco | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive line | Brandt Hurley | Churubusco | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive line | Dane Sebert | Eastside | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive line | Joey Eck | Eastside | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Offensive line | Gunnar Czaja | Eastside | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Kicker | Binyam Biddle | Eastside | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | At-Large | Drew Pliett | Central Noble | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Brody Morgan | Central Noble | ||
| 2022 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Kaden Manth | Churubusco | ||
| 2022 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Owen Davis | Eastside | ||
| 2022 | NECC Big | Honorable Mention | Rosey Stephens | Churubusco | ||
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive line | Croix Haberstock | Churubusco | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive line | Brady Laub | Eastside | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive line | Kolt Gerke | Eastside | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive line | Lincoln Booth | Prairie Heights | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Ethan Skinner | Central Noble | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Cullen Blake | Churubusco | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Ethan Smith | Churubusco | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Linebacker | Dackotia Reed | Eastside | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive back | Kameron Rinker | Churubusco | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive back | Briar Munsey | Eastside | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Defensive back | Carsen Jacobs | Eastside | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | Punter | Brenden Collins | Fremont | |
| 2022 | NECC Big | 1st Team | At-Large | Brennan Gaff | Churubusco | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Jackson Foster | Fremont | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Gage Spalding | Eastside | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Tavvin Kyle | Prairie Heights | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Wyatt Claxton | Fremont | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Caleb Manprasert | Prairie Heights | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Quarterback | Tyler Call | Angola | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Running back | Andre Tagliaferri | Angola | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Running back | Kham Malaivanh | Lakeland | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Wide receiver | Lane King | Angola | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Wide receiver | Parker Skelly | Garrett | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Wide receiver | Owen Troyer | Lakeland | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive line | Jack Archbold | Angola | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive line | Rylan Gebhart | Angola | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive line | Brock Berkey | Fairfield | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive line | Jack O’Connor | Garrett | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Offensive line | Andrew Saggars | West Noble | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Kicker | Carson Mickem | Lakeland | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | At-Large | Seth Pruitt | West Noble | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Brayden Holbrook | Lakeland | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Robert Koskie | Garrett | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Jonathan Schwartz | West Noble | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Lane Gibson | Garrett | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Payton Cowley | Lakeland | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Noah Eash | West Noble | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive line | Jake Land | Angola | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive line | Dayton Lockwood | Fairfield | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive line | Aiden Hunt | Garrett | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive line | Keegan Clark | West Noble | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Kyle Smith | Garrett | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Cody Bickley | Garrett | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Cam Reigling | Lakeland | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Linebacker | Zack Beers | West Noble | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive back | Ethan Miller | Angola | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive back | Cohen Custer | Fairfield | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Defensive back | Wesley Hilbish | West Noble | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | Punter | Drew Yates | West Noble | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | 1st Team | At-Large | Jordan Eash | West Noble | |
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Levi Chaney | Garrett | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | McKale Bottles | West Noble | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Calder Hefty | Garrett | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Mark Wells | Lakeland | ||
| 2022 | NECC Small | Honorable Mention | Xavier Yates | West Noble | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Hansen Haffner | 12 | Carroll |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Avery Cook | 11 | Concordia |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Wide Reciever | Isaac Zay | 12 | Bishop Luers |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Tight End | Brady Rhoad | 11 | Carroll |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Ethan Dodson | 12 | Snider |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Tackle | Caiden Abbs | 11 | Carroll |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Center | Kenyon Davis | 12 | Wayne |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offentive Guard | Jordan King | 12 | North Side |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Offensive Guard | Jackson Bell | 12 | Homestead |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Quarterback | Jimmy Sullivan | 11 | Carroll |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Uriah Buchanen | 12 | Snider |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Brett Fuchs | 12 | Homestead |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Running Back | Mickey Daring | 12 | Bishop Luers |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Kicker | Victor Barreto | 12 | Carroll |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Punter | Dominic Dempsey | 12 | Carroll |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Ashton Pesetski | 12 | Carroll |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive End | Adam Blakey | 11 | Snider |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Will Kelso | 12 | Snider |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Da'Von Haney Jr. | 12 | North Side |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Defensive Tackle | Damiun Jackson | 12 | Bishop Luers |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Middle Linebacker | Lukas Rohrbacher | 12 | Snider |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Middle Linebacker | Kimar Nelson | 11 | Wayne |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Middle Linebacker | Julante Hinton | 12 | Northrop |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Outside Linebacker | Sam Steward | 11 | Homestead |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Outside Linebacker | Josh Masasu | 11 | North Side |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Outside Linebacker | Christian Lozada | 12 | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Cornerback | Adrian Wooten | 11 | Wayne |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Cornerback | Jamarion Kolagbodi | 11 | Snider |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Safety | Braden Steely | 12 | Carroll |
| 2023 | All SAC | 1st Team | Safety | Brandon Logan | 11 | Snider |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Carter Minix | 12 | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Harold Mack | 11 | Wayne |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Wide Reciever | Jerquaden Guilford | 10 | Northrop |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Tight End | Caleb Lehrman | 12 | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Arlondo Sheets | 12 | Homestead |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Tackle | Peyton Alt | 12 | Wayne |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Carter Wilson | 12 | Snider |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Offensive Guard | Luke Giese | 12 | Homestead |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Center | Jake Wilson | 12 | Carroll |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Marcus Cooper | 12 | Wayne |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Ke'ron Billingsley | 12 | Snider |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Kam Johnson | 12 | North Side |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Running Back | Nate Starks | 11 | Carroll |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Kicker | Chase Wennemar | 12 | Snider |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Punter | Dylan Schible | 12 | North Side |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | James Early | 11 | North Side |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Xander Swihart | 12 | Homestead |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Zaire Sullivan | 12 | Wayne |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Wes Javins | 12 | Bishop Luers |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Defensive Tackle | Marcus Logan Jr. | 11 | Northrop |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Middle Linebacker | Cameron Lentz | 12 | Carroll |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Middle Linebacker | Cruz Pursley | 12 | Homestead |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Outside Linebacker | Jacob Sharin | 11 | Wayne |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Outside Linebacker | Justin Anderson | 12 | Carroll |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Cornerback | Jamri Pearson | 11 | North Side |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Cornerback | Arron Robinson | 12 | Northrop |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Cornerback | McKale Woodson | 10 | Bishop Luers |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Safety | Jarius Timberlake-Johnson | 10 | South Side |
| 2023 | All SAC | 2nd Team | Safety | Darion Alexander | 12 | Wayne |
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ethan Springer | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Xavier Garrett | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ben Steigmeyer | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wyatt Tippmann | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Toby Tippmann | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Trent Tippmann | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | John Paul Henry | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Max Brinker | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Owen Zimmerman | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Joseph Schenkel | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Max Carey | Bishop Dwenger | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Michael Brough | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Christian Buxton | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jacob Felger | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dee Hogue | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Gio Jimenez | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Kohen McKenzie | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Finn Saxe | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jaylen White | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tristan Woodcox | Bishop Luers | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jaidon VanPelt | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mason Baughman | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Andrew Rudolph | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Alex Neuhouser | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dajuan Green | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Will Jeffries | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Dylan Beam | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Josh Tillar | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ethan Tranquill | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jackson Miller | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Joseph Nuttle | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brody Beeks | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Evan Brubaker | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Samuel Frisinger | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mason Irmiter | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Emil Keserovic | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Eli Neuhouser | Carroll | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Zack Spielman | Concordia | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jack Belschner | Concordia | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Will Davis | Homestead | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Sterling Swihart | Homestead | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Wyatt Little | Homestead | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | David Callison | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Donlaray Reese Jr. | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Janilan Barksdale-Wilson | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Taiwan Johnson | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ezekiel Cowherd | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jeremiah Lemmon | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Caleb Lanza | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Decorian Pittman | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Mason Widmer | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jaxson Smith | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tyreece Menifee | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jakob Gump | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jaxson Hughes | Northrop | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Maalik Moore | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tristen Newsome | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Caleb Kiengele | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Derrion Goodwin | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Quindale White | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jason Gentry | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jamie Roy | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Quincy Smith | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jeremiah Adams | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Will Holley | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Sahsovion Harris | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Da'Vonce Harris-Moore | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Ean Coburn | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Willie Ivy | North Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | KJ Alexander | South Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jondel Bryant | South Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brian Eldridge | South Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Javon Erby | South Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Cyliss Portee | South Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Josiah Malone | South Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Corte' Wallace | South Side | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Boston Conley | Snider | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jack Langas | Snider | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Austin Ganaway | Snider | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Sam Hatton | Snider | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Pau Lian | Snider | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Landen Fry | Snider | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Tony Hernandez | Snider | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Levi Overholser | Snider | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Brian Rogers | Wayne | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Deonte Williams | Wayne | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Harrison Brooks | Wayne | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Jayden Busche | Wayne | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Martin Lenahs | Wayne | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Robert Castro | Wayne | ||
| 2023 | All SAC | Honorable Mention | Victur Doughty | Wayne | ||
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Quarterback | Zander Brazel | 12 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Running Back | Tyson Reinbold | 12 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Running Back | Tre Bates | 12 | New Haven |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Tight End | Brock Schott | 11 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Receiver | Mylan Graham | 12 | New Haven |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Receiver | Kaden Hurst | 12 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Wide Receiver | Stratton Fuller | 11 | Columbia City |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Center | Joel Yager | 12 | Columbia City |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Guard | Zack Leighty | 12 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Guard | Mason Knoch | 12 | New Haven |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Tackle | Wyatt Birch | 12 | DeKalb |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Tackle | Grant Pattee | 12 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive End | Dylan Velez | 12 | Bellmont |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive End | Connor Leins | 12 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive Lineman | Lucas Sheron | 12 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Defensive Lineman | Tyrin Parks | 12 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Inside Linebacker | Dylan Krehl | 11 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Inside Linebacker | Chris Stewart | 12 | New Haven |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Outside Linebacker | Brett Fuller | 12 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Outside Linebacker | Logan Hatton | 11 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Safety | Kamden Zeisloft | 12 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Safety | Job Hoffman | 12 | Bellmont |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Cornerback | Landin Hoeppner | 11 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Cornerback | Ajani Washington | 12 | New Haven |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Kicker | Austin DeLeon | 12 | Norwell |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Punter | Luke Teusch | 12 | Huntington North |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 1st Team | Specialist | Kaden Hurst | 12 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Quarterback | Donovan Williams | 12 | New Haven |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Running Back | Aidan Monds | 12 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Running Back | Caiden Hinkle | 11 | DeKalb |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Tight End | James Hardy IV | 12 | New Haven |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Receiver | Mason Treesh | 10 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Receiver | Xavier Bell | 10 | DeKalb |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Wide Receiver | Cohen Bailey | 12 | Norwell |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Center | Riley Stewart | 12 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Guard | Ayden Billiard | 12 | Norwell |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Guard | Braylon Braun | 12 | Bellmont |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Tackle | Tucker Reed | 10 | Columbia City |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Tackle | Charles McGrant | 11 | New Haven |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Nic Ley | 11 | DeKalb |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive End | Konner Clark | 12 | New Haven |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive Lineman | Alex Hoffer | 12 | New Haven |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Defensive Lineman | Jake Armstrong | 12 | DeKalb |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Inside Linebacker | Noah McDevitt | 12 | Columbia City |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Inside Linebacker | Blayde King | 12 | DeKalb |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Outside Linebacker | Korin Harris | 12 | New Haven |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Outside Linebacker | Graham Blythe | 11 | DeKalb |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Safety | Ian Stahl | 12 | Columbia City |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Safety | Riley biddle | 10 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Cornerback | Ben Barker | 12 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Cornerback | AJ Ross | 11 | DeKalb |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Kicker | Landon Urban | 12 | Columbia City |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Punter | Riley Stewart | 12 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | 2nd Team | Specialist | Stratton Fuller | 11 | Columbia city |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Quarterback | Kylar Decker | 12 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Running Back | James Getts | 12 | Columbia city |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Running Back | Chrisitan Hatch | 12 | Bellmont |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Tight End | Alex brennan | 11 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Wide Receiver | Caden Pettis | 12 | Dekalb |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Wide Receiver | Keegan Corbin | 12 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Wide Receiver | Landon Swogger | 11 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Center | Cole Mendez | 12 | Bellmont |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Guard | Same bean | 10 | Columbia City |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Guard | Crew Kaylor | 11 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Tackle | Elijah Jacobs | 12 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Tackle | Isaiah Coolman | 10 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Pace Agee | 11 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive lineman | Tristan Roberts | 11 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Defensive lineman | Aiden Kalhoeffer | 12 | Huntington North |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Inside linebacker | Jason teusch | 11 | Huntington North |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Inside linebacker | Jacob Ramey | 11 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Outside linebacker | Kobe Ritchie | 11 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Outside linebacker | Jaxon Keller | 11 | Leo |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Safety | Brady culler | 10 | Dekalb |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Safety | Trace Moser | 12 | Norwell |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Cornerback | Christian Hatch | 12 | Bellmont |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Cornerback | Calvin Dobson | 10 | New Haven |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Kicker | Alex Sprague | 11 | East Noble |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Punter | Brodi Wilson | 10 | DeKalb |
| 2023 | All NE8 | Honorable Mention | Specialist | Xavier Bell | 10 | DeKalb |
| 2023 | All ACAC | 1 Team Offense | Quarterback | Kobe Meyer | 12 | Heritage |
| 2023 | All ACAC | 1 Team Offense | Quarterback | Owen Wanner | 12 | South Adams |
| 2023 | All ACAC | 1 Team Offense | Running Back | Keegan Bluhm | 12 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | 1 Team Offense | Running Back | AJ Myers | 11 | Jay county |
| 2023 | All ACAC | 1 Team Offense | Wide Receiver | Andrew Hunt | 12 | Bluffton |
| 2023 | All ACAC | 1 Team Offense | Wide Receiver | Braden Smith | 12 | Woodlan |
| 2023 | All ACAC | 1 Team Offense | Tight end | Trevor Currie | 12 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | 1 Team Offense | Offensive line | Lain Lengerich | 12 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | 1 Team Offense | Offensive line | Johnny Cruz | 12 | Bluffton |
| 2023 | All ACAC | 1 Team Offense | Offensive line | Brandon Burnam | 12 | Heritage |
| 2023 | All ACAC | 1 Team Offense | Offensive line | Charlie Riddle | 11 | Heritage |
| 2023 | All ACAC | 1 Team Offense | Offensive line | Luke Bauman | 11 | South Adams |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Defense | Defensive line | Cam Fravel | 10 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Defense | Defensive line | Tucker Jenkins | 12 | Bluffton |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Defense | Defensive line | Logan Teichman | 12 | Heritage |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Defense | Defensive line | Bryce Wenk | 12 | Jay county |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Defense | linebacker | Ryan Tester | 12 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Defense | Linebacker | Fletcher Wenger | 12 | Bluffton |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Defense | Linebacker | Caleb Abbott | 12 | Heritage |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Defense | Linebacker | Grant O'Dell | 11 | South Adams |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Defense | Defensive Back | Jack Hamilton | 12 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Defense | Defensive Back | Ben Ramseyer | 12 | Bluffton |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Defense | Defensive back | Landon Hicks | 12 | Heritage |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Defense | Defensive Back | Cam Smith | 12 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Specialists | Punter | Luke Meyer | 12 | Woodlan |
| 2023 | All ACAC | First Team Specialists | Kicker | Trevor Currie | 12 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Offense | Running Back | Colten Bollenbacher | 12 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Offense | Running Back | Drew Fleek | 11 | Woodlan |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Offense | Running Back | Aaron hirschy | 11 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Offense | Running Back | Cooper Craig | 9 | Bluffton |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Offense | Tight End | TZeke Litchfield | 11 | Heritage |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Offense | Offensive line | Nate Geerken | 10 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Offense | Offensive line | Sam Mechling | 12 | Bluffton |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Offense | Offensive line | Joe Hemmelgarn | 12 | Jay County |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Offense | Offensive line | Peyton Long | 12 | Southern Wells |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Offense | Offensive line | Jack Culler | 12 | Woodlan |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Defense | Defensive line | Alex West | 12 | Bluffton |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Defense | Defensive line | Greyson Mullins | 11 | Heritage |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Defense | Defensive line | Isaac Dues | 11 | Jay County |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Defense | Defensive line | Dillian Rameriz | 11 | South Adams |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Defense | Linebacker | Max Kaehr | 11 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Defense | Linebacker | Griffin Morgan | 10 | Bluffton |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Defense | Linebacker | Lucas Strait | 11 | Jay County |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Defense | linebacker | Conner Fear | 12 | South Adams |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Defense | Defensive back | Max Hamilton | 12 | Adams Central |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Defense | Defensive back | Hutch Craighead | 12 | Bluffton |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Defense | Defensive back | Braden Walter | 11 | Heritage |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Defense | Defensive back | Carter Fleek | 11 | Woodlan |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Specialists | Punter | Braxton Betancourt | 12 | Bluffton |
| 2023 | All ACAC | Second Team Specialists | Kicker | Jackson Garcia | 11 | South Adams |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | Quarterback | Brody Morgan | Central Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | Running Back | Angelo Ianucilli | Churubusco | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | Running Back | Linkin Carter | Eastside | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | Wide Rec./Tight End | Gavin Hulsenbeck | Churubusco | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | Wide Rec./Tight End | Tysen Deck | Central Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | Wide Rec./Tight End | Drew Pliett | Central Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | Offensive Line | Jackson Foster | Fremont | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | Offensive Line | Jack Huelsenbeck | Churubusco | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | Offensive Line | Dane Sebert | Eastside | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | Offensive Line | Joey Eck | Eastside | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | Offensive Line | Triton Feichter | Eastside | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | Kicker | Vito Kregel | Fremont | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Offense | At-Large | Wyatt Davis | Eastside | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Defensive Line | Nevin Bloom | Fremont | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Defensive Line | Weston Ott | Churubusco | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Defensive Line | Kris Levitz | Prairie Heights | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Defensive Line | Adam Marker | Central Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Linebacker | Steve Burkholder | Fremont | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Linebacker | Weston Rinker | Churubusco | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Linebacker | Gage Spalding | Eastside | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Linebacker | Brayden Kirchner | Central Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Defensive Back | Brennan Gaff | Churubusco | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Defensive Back | EJ Miller | Eastside | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Defensive Back | Nolen Steury | Eastside | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Punter | Toby Biddle | Eastside | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | At-Large | Ethan Smith | Churubusco | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Honorable Mention | Jacob McClain | Eastside | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Honorable Mention | Ethan Barnes | Eastside | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Honorable Mention | Jacob Chenoweth | Central Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Small | Defense | Honorable Mention | Walker McCrea | Prairie Heights | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | Quarterback | Drew Yates | West Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | Running Back | Seth Pruitt | West Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | Running Back | Sean Conley | Lakeland | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | Wide Rec./Tight End | Lane King | Angola | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | Wide Rec./Tight End | Keyan Arroyo | Lakeland | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | Wide Rec./Tight End | McKale Bottles | West Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | Offensive Line | Payton Manahan | Angola | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | Offensive Line | Ethan Hochstetler | Fairfield | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | Offensive Line | Payton Cowley | Lakeland | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | Offensive Line | Bradey Shields | West Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | Offensive Line | Keegan Clark | West Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | Kicker | Carson Mickem | Lakeland | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Offense | At-Large | Brayden Holbrook | Lakeland | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Defensive Line | Ethan Schmucker | Fairfield | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Defensive Line | Aiden Hunt | Garrett | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Defensive Line | Austyn McFall | Lakeland | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Defensive Line | Jordan Eash | West Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Linebacker | Brayden Nusbaum | Garrett | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Linebacker | Bo Kerns | Lakeland | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Linebacker | Nolan Parks | West Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Linebacker | Cam Riegling | Lakeland | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Defensive Back | Micah Steury | Angola | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Defensive Back | Calder Hefty | Garrett | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Defensive Back | Xavier Yates | West Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Punter | Bradyn Williams | Fairfield | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | At-Large | Braden Toigo | Angola | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | At-Large | Jaylun Shaffer | West Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Breckan Maran | Fairfield | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Hunter Kauffman | Fairfield | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Nate Wells | Garrett | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Sawyer Ernsberger | Fairfield | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Blake Metzger | Fairfield | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Luke Holcomb | Garrett | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Caleb Borkholder | Fairfield | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Jacob Maldonado | West Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Parker Skelly | Garrett | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Cole Frost | Lakeland | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Nefty Silva | West Noble | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Camdyn Woods | Garrett | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Camden Ruble | Garrett | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | David Westropp | Garrett | |
| 2023 | NECC Big | Defense | Honorable Mention | Chuck Shackow | Lakeland | |
| Season | Type | Honor | Position | Player | Year | School |
